Review: ‘The Most Expensive Orgy in History’
By Oscar Duffy

The Fitzgerald’s are possibly the most mythologised figures of the 1920s literary world. First Theatre Company’s ‘The Most Expensive Orgy in History’ explores both during peak success. Scott (Jack De Deney) is producing more work than ever and working on The Great Gatsby. Zelda (Daisy Hargreaves) is surrounded by admirers and lives a life of excess. However, the play digs beneath the surface to expose the insecurities of their marriage, and their egos. The strength of the play is how it captures that contrast, through ambitious writing, energetic direction and a selection of moving performances.
The production is one which oozes style. Walking into Durham Union Debating Chamber immediately transports you to the familiar world of the Jazz Age. On stage is a desk topped with a typewriter, crumpled paper and a selection of half drunken bottles. The band (who are consistently impressive throughout the production) ease you in with slow jazz evoking the era that plays such a central part to the story. It is worth specifically noting the excellent lighting choices of tech Directors George Chivers and Hugo Lyon. Scenes are a mix of warm yellows and oranges which accentuate the fantastical and slightly off kilter nature of the characters and events.
The production is one which oozes style
The script is also incredibly ambitious. Writers Alex Ottie and Conor Norrington have constructed a dense piece of drama, something witty and insightful that echoes the voice of Scott himself. Admittedly, at first the dialogue is a little jarring. Constant metaphor threatens to overshadow genuinely impactful material. But as the show progresses, the writing becomes much more focused. The scenes in the second half are especially good, and this is due to much more intimate and ultimately less showy dialogue.
This intimacy is aided by some very accomplished performances. De Deney is a charismatic Scott, delivering a huge amount of fast paced dialogue with indefatigable energy and charm. He is able to make Scott both sympathetic and unlikable and on stage he is a constant presence. However, the true standouts are the leading actresses, most notably Daisy Hargreaves as the manic but deeply insecure Zelda. Through her extremely expressive face she never breaks character and the audience is able to see a huge range of emotion, from excited to despairing.
Equally impressive albeit with less material is Anna Birakos as Daisy, who shares a particularly electric scene with Zelda. She brings an impressive physicality to her roles, making full use of the stage and strutting with a confidence that contrasts beautifully with the timid Hargreaves. The supporting cast have much less to do than the two lead Fitzgerald’s but Birakos manages to make a huge impression. That is not to say the rest of the cast are not impressive. Darrius Kudiabor-Thompson and Alex Berridge-Dunn both provide a nice amount of levity to the drama, but they and the rest of the cast admittedly have little to do.
Some very accomplished performances
Emily Oliver and Natasha Ketel make the clever directorial choice however to use these minor characters to fill the stage, dancing between scenes and standing at the back drinking and smoking. It works to ground the play constantly within the period whilst also making sure there is always something to be looking at. It adds to the vibrancy and energy and makes the more intimate scenes more noticeable.
Overall, ‘The Most Expensive Orgy in History’ is sometimes a little too dense, but the script is consistently entertaining, the direction snappy and performances often fantastic. It is an enjoyable night of theatre and well worth seeing.
Image by First Theatre Company
