Democracy under the microscope
By Oscar Duffy
No day goes by without someone mentioning Brexit. While many are bored by this, in essence, what the past three years have taught us is that an opinion on Brexit is just as much about how you define democracy as it is whether or not you want to stay in the European Union. Remainers have become by default advocates of representative democracy, emphasising the supremacy of Parliament in order to smooth over the result of the referendum in 2016. Leavers take a different approach, bypassing the idea of trusteeship and appealing to the sense of direct democracy and people power that existed in the ethos of Brexit, tying the referendum to the taking back control narrative that defined the campaign.
The very idea of what British democracy has deteriorated and the product of Brexit will not be a stronger or weaker Britain outside of the EU but a deeply damaged democracy, defined by politicians bowing to smaller pressure groups rather than parliamentary process.
By definition, referendums are advisory affairs
Both sides are to blame. This, in itself, is a shocking admission. Standing on the outside of Brexit looking in is about as impossible these days as having a neutral opinion on Donald Trump. But a neutral view of two sides using equally aggressive tactics allows us to see the ridiculousness and hypocrisy of the whole situation.
Let us look to the most obvious form of democracy that can be defended in this debate: the referendum in 2016, the vote that started it all, or indeed ended it depending on where you stand. By definition, referendums are advisory affairs, meant to guide government and parliamentary policy through an explicit expression of public sentiment. This is the argument often put forward by Remainers and while true, is thin. While policy may state that referendums are not binding, why put the question to the people in the first place, if you don’t have the intention of following through?
Besides, the argument that the referendum has no legitimacy was not shouted so emphatically back in 2017 when article 50 was triggered. It’s only now when the process has become so overwrought that politicians are resorting to calling into question the very democratic credentials of the initial vote.
Rhetoric around the referendum is toxic on both sides
Yet rhetoric around the referendum is toxic on both sides. This is not to say that the Leave side’s almost fundamentalist defence of the referendum is justified. Indeed, very much of the conversation from their end has also been engulfed by strawman arguments. The vote of the 17.4 million (a figure so tiresomely proclaimed and revered that anyone included in that number has seemingly reached a stage of martyrdom) is the rallying cry for anyone who wants to defend Brexit in any form.
In Britain, acts of democracy are part of a continuous process. The introduction of the Fixed-Term Parliaments Act ensures a consistent turnaround of government and
If elected politicians delegate important decisions to the public, why are they elected to make decisions in the first place?
The uneasy nature of direct democracy thus opens the idea of representatives and trusteeship, the very essence of the UK parliamentary system. This and referendums are held in opposition. If elected politicians delegate important decisions to the public, why are they elected to make decisions in the first place? This is the argument that Remainers are beginning to cling to. The recent prorogation of parliament saw many lamentations about the loss of democracy drawing obvious allusions to tyranny and anti-democratic behaviour. The loss of parliamentary scrutiny in the Brexit process is seen as the biggest assault to democracy, even if those in parliament oppose the result of the referendum that they called, and more importantly, the Article 50 legislation they passed.
A perfect microcosm of the impossible conundrum between parliamentary and direct democracy is found in the Liberal Democrat proposal to stop Brexit should they gain a majority in the next election. On the one hand, cancelling Brexit without a second referendum is a denial of the 2016 referendum, the nightmare of hard-line Brexiteers in the European Research Group and a denial of the legitimacy of direct democracy. It applies the arguments of the supremacy of parliamentary power through the theory that a majority in the House of Commons is a greater indication of public will than a referendum three years ago.
Democracy is in the public consciousness more than ever, but can anyone really define it?
However, while this policy can be backed up by theory, does the rhetoric surrounding the importance of direct democracy mean that carrying out this policy would be the straw that broke the camel’s back? Would the perceived breakdown of democracy lead to the actual breakdown of it? None of this is clear. The only undeniable argument is that democracy is in the public consciousness more than ever, but can anyone really define it?
Image via pxhere: CC0 Public Domain
