Jeremy Vine: “Power is shifting now from expertise to experience”
By Alexandra Beste and Pip Murrison
Profile speaks to journalist and broadcaster Jeremy Vine about his time at Durham, climate change, and the shift from expertise to experience in politics and media.
Between interviews and talks at the Durham Union and the Cathedral, Jeremy Vine is in high demand when he comes to visit his alma mater. Yet despite his busy schedule, the radio and television broadcaster is happy to do a walk-and-talk interview through the streets of Durham with Palatinate.
Strolling from Dunelm House to Palace Green, Jeremy easily takes on the role of tour guide and points out Hatfield College as we cross Kingsgate Bridge. “This was my college. I was C stairs, third floor. I had one of the windows looking out the back so I had this view (of the river).” He jokes, “I remember being told off by some of the rowers because I put my window open and played really loud music. The rowers came up and were quite beefy.”
Jeremy recalls some of the antics that went on at the Bailey college when he was a student there in the mid-1980s. “There was a thing where people would be thrown in the pond if they – male and female – if they were regarded as not being good enough looking to use the bar, which was very silly.”
Outside of college, Jeremy spent a lot of his time at Palatinate, serving as the paper’s editor in Epiphany Term of 1986. During our stroll, he gets excited when we show him an old copy of one of his editions. The headline – ‘Foul Play’ – triggers his memory.
“We were talking about foul play which was the… union society, isn’t it? That guy, Richard Calland… had overspent on his printing. Somebody who did not want him to be elected went down to the printing company to get his receipts and having got the receipts, they then delivered a kind of revelation on it. So basically, his election was struck down so it caused a lot of bother.”
Looking more closely at the old newspaper, he describes how the editors used to layup the newspaper by hand.
‘It was basically all typed on the same typewriter which was electric and then it was put together by taking the paper out of the typewriter and gluing it to card that then went down to the printers.’ He quips, “It does look quite tragic, really.”
After his Palatinate days, Jeremy went on to pursue a career in journalism at the BBC. He first worked as a reporter for the Today programme on Radio 4, then served as a Westminster correspondent. In the late 1990s, he became the broadcasting company’s Africa correspondent. One moment that sticks out to him from this time is a speech by Nelson Mandela.
“He had made a promise that he would put running water in everyone’s house… He was going to put in the last tap this morning. And he made a speech about how politics was about that tap. It was the most amazing thing. I thought ‘his reputation is incredible, he will die as a legend… but he still has to put in that tap’. To me that’s what it’s all about, that tap.”
By now, our walk-and-talk has brought us to Palace Green, but Jeremy still has time for one more question before his sound check at the Cathedral. We ask him how the recent Extinction Rebellion protest in London, during which journalists were prevented from entering the BBC, relates to issues of journalistic impartiality.
“I think with the climate there’s no doubt that it is actually happening and that it is predominantly man-made; those two things have been brought to us by science so I would not want to question that.”
He continues, “I think the issue about protesting is if breaking the law is acceptable: whether we, the BBC, should be against law breaking because breaking the law is bad, or whether we should be reporting completely impartially and say that this is so important that it might be justified. I think the key is just to get all voices on.’
On this note, we bid him “see you later” until his speech at the Cathedral. Funnily enough, his opening words that evening seem to add a final note to his city tour, as he says, “I love this place. This is the most beautiful building in the world.”
In the Cathedral, later that day under the header ‘What on Earth is Going On?’, Jeremy explores the current state of national and international politics. A central focus is Brexit, which he at one point compares to the Eagles’ song, “Hotel California”. He explains, “In the middle of the song, it uses the line: ‘You can check out anytime you want, but you can never leave.’ That is the status we are now in with the EU.”
In this context, he observes how “power is shifting now from expertise to experience – from people who study things to people who experience them.” Drawing on his experience as the host of his own programme on Radio 2, Jeremy explains, “To talk about a dynamic inside a large family, you book a mother of five. You don’t book the RFC to talk about cars breaking down, you book someone who’s stuck in a van in a hard shoulder on the M6.”
This phenomenon affects both the world of politics as well as the world of journalism. ‘There are more and more incidents where experience defeats expertise… In the olden days we relied on journalists to tell us stuff, they were gods in a way, people like Sir Robin Day… The stories are now being turned around. You move from listening to astronomers telling us about planets, to hearing the story directly from astronauts.’
He jokes that this is “excruciating for me, ladies and gentlemen, but maybe that’s the point – the listeners run it now.” But Jeremy’s message is clear: there is power in the individual voice. “The audience
Image by Jack Taylor
