Tim Luckhurst: ‘Speaking truth to power’

Profile speaks to journalist and academic Tim Luckhurst about the Romanian Revolution, the ethical duties of reporting, and the challenges facing modern media.

By Alexandra Beste

From pursuing a career in journalism to working within academia, Tim Luckhurst is a person accustomed to asking questions. Now that he is joining the Durham community as Principal of South College and Associate Pro-Vice-Chancellor Engagement, I decided to turn the tables and ask him questions for a change.

As Principal of South College, Tim will be taking on the responsibility of launching Durham’s newest college. To some, this challenge may seem daunting, but this is not Tim’s first rodeo.

He explains that as an undergraduate at Robinson College, Cambridge, “I had the joy of going to a new college at an ancient university and taking part in creating its traditions, its societies… I really want to bring some of the excitement and pioneering experience that I enjoyed as an undergraduate and hopefully inspire that at South College.”

Since his university days, Tim has continued to bring this ‘pioneering spirit’ to new projects. He was one of the senior members of the team that launched Radio 5 Live at the BBC, the founding head of the Centre for Journalism at the University of Kent, and the founder of KMTV, ‘the only university-based commercial television station in the UK’.

What links all of these endeavours is his dedication to journalism. At the age of 26 years old, Tim first joined the world of journalism, working for the Today programme at Radio 4.

“I wanted to be a journalist for one absolutely straightforward reason: I wanted to do something that was really important, and I think that journalism’s role in informing democracy, in speaking truth to power, and in holding power to account is an essential foundation of democracy.’”

“I also recognized very in my life that journalism… is one of the few jobs in which you can do something that really matters whilst also having an exciting career and not doing the same thing every day. It never let me down in that respect.”

A clear example of this was Tim’s experience covering the Romanian Revolution. One day in 1989, his editor came into the newsroom and stated that there was trouble being reported in the western Romanian town of Timișoara.

Tim recounts, “I’d come to work with my wallet, my passport and my credit card, because that’s what we were always told to do. The editor said, “Who’s got wallet, passport and credit card?” I said, ‘I have’… and literally ten minutes later we were in a cab to Heathrow.”

After landing in what was then Yugoslavia and assuring the car rental desk at Belgrade airport that “under no circumstances” would they take the car anywhere near Romania, the reporters drove straight to the border of a country which had not let in Western journalists for several decades.

“We sat at the border for nearly eight hours whilst the border guards worked out what they could do. It was pretty clear though that the regime was falling because there were Securitate men fleeing across the field beside the border post.”

“That is the greatest ethical duty that a reporter has – you must tell the truth.”

Finally, they were allowed to enter Romania. It was inside the Eastern Bloc state that Tim witnessed the “brutal fighting between those who supported the democratic cause and those were defending the regime.”

His “single most powerful memory” is from Boxing Day, 1989. Tim and his colleague were at the rebel-held radio station in Timișoara when news came from the capital that the Romanian President and Romanian Communisty Party General Secretary, Nicolae Ceaușescu, had been executed.

“We made the mistake of saying that was a tragedy, by which we meant that we felt that even though he’d been an appalling man, he deserved a fair trial. One of the rebels looked at me and said, ‘Yes you’re right, we should have tortured him first’ – which is certainly not what we meant.”

Following this first experience in conflict reporting, Tim went on to cover the Gulf War in 1991 for BBC Radio 4 and the conflicts in Northern Ireland during the mid-1990s for Radio 5 Live. As a reporter for The Scotsman and other newspapers, he also wrote about the violence in Kosovo and Serbia during the disintegration of Yugoslavia.

Referring to the lessons he learned while reporting in such high-pressure situations, Tim explains, “When people tell you stories of the other side’s brutality, you have to be very careful not to be used as an agent of propaganda, but to check thoroughly and to the best of your ability whether those allegations are true before you refer to them.”

He adds, “As a reporter, you have a great responsibility to accuracy. That is the greatest ethical duty that a reporter has  – you must tell the truth.”

Here, Tim’s academic focus intersects with his journalistic work. Taking an interest in evacuation policies, conscientious objection, and the area bombing of German cities, he studies how journalists challenged the government during World War Two.

“The duty to speak truth to power is never more compelling than in a democracy at war”, he states, “and the Second World War tests the journalist’s duty to perform that role.”

“The duty to speak truth to power is never more compelling than in a democracy at war”

While Tim’s academic research looks to the past, the former reporter also deliberates on the nature of journalism in the twenty-first century.

“I think that the biggest single problem journalism faces at the moment is not the excellence of professional reporting … the problem is that vast numbers of people are not reading, watching or listening to that reporting,” he argues. “They are instead taking their news from the echo chamber of social media. That is not news. That is unmediated prejudice and opinion.”

Tim views this as an issue of legal accountability towards accuracy. “Newspapers and broadcasters are treated as publishers. And as publishers, we are responsible for the content we publish…Facebook, Google, the social media giants deny that they are publishers… If they were treated as publishers, then they would have to take care to ensure that everything they published was accurate, decent, and honest.”

Another cause for concern is the issue of offence. “I worry that we have begun to confuse offence and harm,” he explains. “I take the view that we can choose to be offended, and we can choose not to be offended… I don’t think we can choose not to be harmed.”

“I take the view that we can choose to be offended, and we can choose not to be offended… I don’t think we can choose not to be harmed.”

It is on this note that Tim gives a call to action. “I think that by hearing those with whom I profoundly disagree, I equip myself to argue effectively against them… We should never close our ears to them because that is to deny ourselves knowledge, information and wisdom.”

Photo by Durham University