Johnson’s immigration proposals: hit or miss?

FOR: Mary Kate Rylands

The government’s recent proposals for a points-based immigration system have been met with outrage from many senior members of the Labour Party. It has been characterised as exclusive and elitist, implying that one must ‘buy’ entry into our nation. Labour’s disdain for the proposals is, however, built on a hypocritical foundation. A points-based immigration system has the potential to tackle the inequality of opportunity which permeates our society.

Labour’s disdain for the proposals is built on a hypocritical foundation.

Characteristically, Labour has sided with the interests of businesses, and not necessarily the people whose votes they wish to win. Implicit in their outrage is the defence of cheap labour and all that it entails. How can you really blame them though? Who will pick our broccoli? Work in our abattoirs? Clean our homes and staff our NHS?

Incentivising those UK nationals to work would be a good place to start. Although on paper overall employment is at record highs, hidden in the numbers lies the fact that over 800,000 18 to 24 year olds in this country are not in education, employment or training. If a points-based system is implemented as proposed nothing concrete will change overnight. But, with time inevitably the attitudes of those businesses reliant on low- skilled workers will have to change.

Whether they come in the form of increased wages, better training or more secure job contracts, incentives will have to be made to get UK nationals to fill vacant jobs. This will come with challenges. It may, in certain cases, simply serve to accelerate a move towards robotic systems, more advanced technology and the replacement of people all together. However, in other areas it has the potential to raise wages and standards in the workplace. If a job and all that it entails is not satisfactory to someone born in this country, then why should it be considered fit for anyone?

AGAINST: Oscar Duffy

Ever since Brexit grievances were so highly dominated by the issue of increased migration from Eastern Europe (a trend which began in 2004 when the European Union began to exponentially expand), we all knew that a hardline policy stemming immigration numbers was coming. The Conservative government have been advocating for an Australian style points based system for some time now, so this should not be a surprising headline. But, it’s still a relatively shameful thing to see put into words, and simply exemplifies the regressive nature of British policy.

Language wise, too often, migrants are hindered by their inability to speak English which bars them from seeking employment effectively and undermines their effectiveness at integrating into communities. If anything, it sows discord and division, and has contributed to anti-migrant sentiments among the less openminded British public. But language requirements are an age old issue that have caused numerous global controversies, as it discourages pluralism the globalism that Britain (as a world leader) should take pride in. For example, the USA spent the turn of the 20th century (over a hundred years ago) debating the necessity of a literacy test for incoming economic migrants from European nations. It was a controversial move back then and its pervasiveness a century on should make anyone who calls themselves a progressive uncomfortable.

There is also the issue that the points based system places faux moral grandstanding above the economic realities of a globalised world. No one appreciates corporations exploiting vulnerable foreign workers for less money than British counterparts, but while this should be reformed, cutting off low skilled migration stems the valuable influx of a workforce in some of the most vital areas of employment, most notably the social care sector.

It has contributed to anti-migrant sentiments among the less open- minded British public

According to the MAC (Migration Advisory Committee), many of those employed in this area fail to meet wage and skills threshold. I expect the system to be seriously revised once these implications come to light.

Photo: Michelle Donolan Chippenham via Flickr