Formula One’s ‘Rookie of the Year’: who will it be?

By Emily Doughty

The 2023 Formula One season is three months away but already speculation is starting over who will clinch the title, with many expecting a three-way race between Redbull, Mercedes and Ferrari.

However, another title which is also being debated is ‘Rookie of the Year’.

With six titles between them in various other series including Formula Two, Formula Three and Formula E, the competition is expected to be tight between the three contenders: Oscar Pastri, Nyck De Vries and Logan Sargent.

Oscar Piastri

Out of all the rookies it is undeniable that Oscar Piastri is coming in with the most pressure and expectation upon his shoulders. His signing for McLaren over Alpine – where he was part of their drivers’ academy – was one of the most controversial points of the drivers “silly season”, seeing him being announced twice for two different teams.

The pressure also facing Pastri comes from who he is replacing. Daniel Ricciardo, while having a weak season in 2022, was undeniably a fan favourite and a driver who could perform in a car which suited him. Piastri is not only having to compete against his teammate, but he is also having to compete against a ghost to which all his performances will be compared.

Piastri is also taking on a car which has been proven to perform. Lando Norris, Piastri’s new teammate, was able to secure the coveted ‘best of the rest’ spot in the Drivers’ Championship, finishing 7th.

Piastri’s shot at being Rookie of the Year will be determined by his ability to perform under pressure. It is undeniable that he is a good driver, after winning the F2 and F3 champions back-to-back, and he is in a car which is capable of bringing him to the front of midfield.

However, with Alpine expected to have fixed their reliability issues, it is likely the front of the midfield will be more competitive. If Piastri can deal with the pressure and be equal to Norris, he stands a chance of being the Rookie of the Year.

Piastri’s shot at being Rookie of the Year will be determined by his ability to perform under pressure

Nyck de Vries

Nyck de Vries is an unusual rookie. The 27-year-old, older than others before him, comes into the 2023 season having finished joint 20th (with Logan Sargent’s predecessor Nicholas Latifi) in the Drivers’ Championship last year, after he stepped in for Alex Albon in Monza.

De Vries also has proven himself in F2 and Formula E where he has been able to get consistent victories and power his team to success. Unlike Piastri and Sargent, De Vries is also not replacing a weaker driver. Pierre Gasly, De Vries’ predecessor, was the stronger driver on the Alpha Tauri team and this expectation has seemingly fallen on their new driver too.

Helmut Marko has said he expects Nyck De Vries to be “the team leader” going into the new season. With the confidence of the team going into the year, it is likely that De Vries will perform well, especially against his teammate, Yuki Tsunoda.

Logan Sargent

Unlike the other rookies, Logan Sargent comes into the 2023 season with significantly less expectation on him. Williams announced their intention to sign Sargent even before he had the necessary points to achieve a super licence and ran him in extra sessions to make sure he had the points.

The new Williams driver also comes in with a less impressive junior record than the other three drivers, only finishing 4th in the F2 Championship, something that both Nyck de Vries and Oscar Piastri previously won.

However, it would be harsh to think that the new Williams driver had no chance in the Rookie competition. When competing against Piastri in F3 the American driver came 3rd, even having two victories in the season. While he has enjoyed less success, it is undeniable he is talented.

Sargent will likely be competing only against his teammate so will be unable to show his talent in his first year

Nevertheless, even if Sargent performed well would he be able to win Rookie of the year in a Williams? Having lost their team principal and still not having named his replacement, Williams looks to be a rudderless ship.

No major advancements are expected, and it is unlikely the car will have improved enough to catch up with the rest of the field. Sargent will likely be competing only against his teammate so will be unable to show his talent in his first year.

A two-horse race

So, who will be rookie of the year? It will likely be a two-horse race between Nyck De Vries and Oscar Piastri. Logan Sargent realistically does not have the car to fight for any standings other than 19th or 20th and will likely not be able to beat the experience and talent of Alex Albon.

Between Nyck De Vries and Oscar Piastri, I expect that the Alpha Tauri driver will be able to nudge the title. Unlike the McLaren speedster, De Vries will be the stronger driver on the team and unlike Piastri will not be under the same pressure to perform, especially compared to their teammates.

Only time will tell; however, what can be guaranteed is that these rookies will certainly bring more excitement to the upcoming 2023 season.

Image: Takayuki Suzuki via Flickr