Durham students react to results of the preferendum

By Emily Doughty

Durham students and staff have responded to the result of the preferendum, which saw nearly 60% of all students vote to support all industrial action. 

While many students and staff have voiced their support for the decision, celebrating its result, including Durham UCU and SU officers, some have criticised the decision to hold the vote in the first place. Some postgraduate students said that the decision means that the “SU have tarnished their reputation”. 

In a statement to Palatinate, the SU said that the vote  was “a clear example of the SU’s democracy providing students, including research students who are postgraduate members of UCU, the opportunity to gain a strong democratic mandate on an issue they care about”.

The result was celebrated by the Durham branch of the University and College Union (UCU) who said “Great to see that students @durhamSU backing all forms of industrial action. Student & staff unity is the only way to fight for and build the system of higher education we all need”.

This was echoed by DUstudents4staff, a campaign group which had pushed for students to vote to support all industrial action. On their Twitter they said “We wanted to say a massive thanks to everyone involved in the campaign, and to everyone who voted. This is a decisive result that sends a clear message to management, now is the time for action!”

“This is a decisive result that sends a clear message to management, now is the time for action!”

DUstudents4staff

Durham SU officers Joshua Freestone and Jack Ballingham also celebrated the result with Mr Freestone saying “So immensely proud of this! Thanks so much to everyone who helped in the campaign and to all those who voted to support our staff. This is a decisive mandate for change, and sends a clear message”.

However some postgraduate students questioned why a vote should have been held in the first place. Cait Jobson, a PhD student said on Twitter that it was “A shame that I even had to vote for a students union to support me (a student) who also teaches”. Mitch Walker, another PhD student said “It’s absolutely ridiculous that this was ever even up for debate, let alone put to a vote”.

The postgraduate branch of the UCU also released a statement on behalf of their members on the result. While they celebrated the result calling “a clear rejection of division within the student body” they were critical of the board of Trustees’ decision to call a referendum. 

In the statement they said “the institution that is the SU have tarnished their reputation amongst unionised PGRs. Our right as SU members to be supported in the fight for better pay in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis should never have been put to a vote.

“Their communications should not have been neglectful of their own members who have gone on strike, and they should not be working with university leadership to undermine UCU representation of postgraduates who teach – an especially egregious manoeuvre when they have been questioning our right to strike.”

“It’s absolutely ridiculous that this was ever even up for debate, let alone put to a vote”

mitch walker

Durham UCU postgraduates said in communication with Palatinate that this statement was in reference to the Universities new HR committee, where Joe McGarry has previously said that a “PG representative from the SU” would be on the committee. 

The group said they don’t even know who this representative was or have any relationship with them, and have seen this as being denied representation with the University. They see this as being denied representation.  

However, the membership of this committee is yet to be finalised, with the University Council actively recruiting for volunteers to sit on the committee. 

The PGR’s statement went on to say that while they appreciated the support of Joshua Freestone and Jack Ballingham, they “condemn unaccountable Durham SU trustees for undermining their democratic mandate and authority. The role of a trustee as defined by the Charity Commission and by Durham SU itself to ensure the SU operated within the law, not to steer policy which is the remit of the democratically elected sabbatical officers”. 

The Charity Commision does say that the role of a trustee is to make sure the SU is operated within its “governing documents and the law”, Durham SU’s governance documents allows for the trustees to call a referendum as outlined within its Article of Association. 

“It is unfortunate that Durham UCU PGRs have no confidence in the SU as an institution to support us going forward.”

In a statement regarding these comments, the Durham Students’ Union spokesperson said “UCU members think UCU members should have the right to spaces in University decision making currently reserved for students, and would shut out students who don’t want to join their union from being represented. They’re entitled to that view, but we disagree.”

“UCU members think UCU members should have the right to space in University decision making currently reserved for students”

durham su spokesperson

Some students also criticised Durham SU for not concentrating on other issues impacting students, with Dan Lonsdale saying on Twitter that “now that the jobsworths are happy maybe we could address the actual problems facing students rather than making them up?”

In a statement, a Durham SU spokesperson said, “A democratic vote by students to support industrial action is a clear example of the SU’s democracy providing students, including research students who are postgraduate members of UCU, the opportunity to gain a strong democratic mandate on an issue they care about.

“That they have been successful in doing so is a credit to their passion and commitment to this issue, but that passion and commitment does not make their opinion the only student opinion entitled for consideration. 

“While at the time of comment Palatinate had not included the voices of students who supported other policy positions in the referendum, this was in fact over 40% of voters. Recognising these students’ rights to have a say does not ‘undermine’ the rights of those with a different opinion.

“Durham SU commissioned research in 2020 into how Durham students wanted to be involved in SU decision making, 89% agreed they wanted to vote directly on more SU policy. Industrial Action will impact the experience of most students this year, and Durham SU’s governing documents are clear that a referendum was desirable, and possible, and entirely consistent with the way things are meant to happen.

“Durham SU’s elected leaders, collectively, decided to hold this referendum. They recognised that any organisation with elected leaders has a continuing responsibility to consult students, and students should make decisions by democratic vote.”

Image Credit: Amana Moore