‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’: The 21st Century’s Most Interesting Rom-Com?
Michel Gondry’s (picture above) Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind bagged 6th place on BBC Culture’s Best Films of the 21st Century, a list compiled by 177 critics across 6 continents. Despite being one of the most widely-loved entries in a relatively esoteric top ten, can this quirky and oddball flick really rank among the greatest offerings of the last 16 years? Simon Fearn investigates.
As rom-coms go, you don’t get much more offbeat than Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Michel Gondry’s soulful film stars an unusually restrained Jim Carey as Joel, whose pre-Valentine’s Day blues are compounded by the news that his wacky ex-girlfriend Clementine (Kate Winslet) has decided to professionally erase him from her memory. Joel resolves to undergo the memory erasing procedure too, but as his memories of the relationship began to slip away, he realises the significance of what he’s about to lose.
Eternal Sunshine was one of the first ‘really good’ films I saw, part of a bunch of movies which made me realise there was more to life than just the latest blockbuster. I was thrilled and surprised in equal measure when it ended up in the Beeb’s top ten – it wasn’t even nominated for Best Film at the Academy Awards, despite screenwriter Charlie Kaufman, Gondry and Pierre Bismuth bagging the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay.
It seems to have stood the test of time though, and is probably among the most widely-loved films in the Beeb’s sometimes obscurely ‘arty’ top ten. The idea for a memory-wiping corporation originally came from Bismuth as the basis for an art project: he planned to send strangers a card like the one Joel receives informing them they have been wiped from the memory of someone they know. Thankfully he was dissuaded from this slightly tasteless prank, but his friend Gondry thought it would be a brilliant idea for a film, and so Eternal Sunshine was born.
There is so much to love about the movie: the honest and surprisingly brutal way Joel and Clementine’s relationship is portrayed; the awesome practical effects Gondry uses to take us inside Joel’s mind (forced perspectives and perfect scene transitions instead of lots of CGI); the brilliant premise. Kaufman has track record for cerebral and somewhat bizarre screenplays, including two brilliant Spike Jonze collaborations (Being John Malkovich and Adaptation), but Eternal Sunshine feels more accessible and warm-hearted than Malkovich’s exploration of the extremes of human behaviour; its cleverness is tempered with genuine and relatable emotion.
Viewed twelve years in retrospect, perhaps Eternal Sunshine no longer feels as fresh as it used to. The rom-com trope of “quirky and impulsive girl re-energises the life of soulful but socially awkward guy” has never been particularly novel, but in recent years it’s inescapable. Eight months after Eternal Sunshine came the once-cult-but-now-largely-reviled Garden State (which featured Natalie Portman teaching Zach Braff how to be less tortured), and a string of similar films eventually led Nathan Rabin to coin the now-unavoidable term Manic Pixie Dream Girl. Winslet’s Clementine is undoubtedly more than a plot device or a male fantasy despite sharing much of the MPDG’s aesthetic, but particularly the early scenes in which she interacts with Carey seem rife with unnervingly familiar cinematic clichés. Kaufman’s screenplay does go on to explode the MPDG myth before it was given a name, think of how genuinely horrible Clementine can be to Joel as their relationship peters out or her speech in the library complaining “too many guys think I’m a concept, or I complete them, or I’m gonna make them alive.” Despite this, when you watch the film now it still feels haunted by reams of cultural baggage and oft-repeated tropes.
Perhaps as a result of not ageing too well, Eternal Sunshine also now seems self-consciously quirky in quite an irritating way, largely because of the chromatic fickleness of Clementine’s hair and Jon Brion’s score which turns the kook up to 11. The whole concept of Joel joyriding around his memories with a presumably imaginary and idealised version of Clementine may be very pretty to look at, but perhaps distracts from the emotional thwack of the obliteration of Joel’s most precious memories and the drastic way his relationship with the real Clementine heads South. The fantasy element and lightness of tone are part of the film’s appeal and give it a great deal of light and shade, but sometimes this means the kind of enjoyment you get from Eternal Sunshine is that of watching a hugely intelligent rom-com. It may be the polar opposite of Love Actually, but for such a high-concept film Eternal Sunshine has its fair share of whimsy.
Nevertheless, Eternal Sunshine is the best exploration I know of how to deal with the simultaneously happy and painful memories of a broken relationship (a clue: probably best not to wipe all traces of your ex from your mind). It shows you that though the vast majority of relationships eventually go awry, this doesn’t make the now-faded love any less valuable or the mistakes made any less essential to being a better lover in the future. Though I’m not sure ‘6th Best Film of the 21st Century’ is a very comfortable fit, there is something belligerently profound about Eternal Sunshine which still manages to take your breath away.
‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ is available to watch on Amazon Prime. Click here to see how many of your favourite films ended up in the BBC’s 100 Best Films of the 21st Century.
Photograph: Lionel Allorge
