Harry Potter and the Cursed Child review: ‘magical’
By Florianne Humphrey
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child has been the most hotly anticipated play this year. It’s the first time the Potter franchise has taken to the stage and the first time JK Rowling has developed a narrative for Harry’s adult life hinted at the end of The Deathly Hallows. It’s also a play shrouded in mystery. Just like The Mousetrap, JK Rowling urged fans on Twitter to #KeepTheSecrets and it’s true that, after seeing the play, a lot of its power comes from the element of surprise.
A review of this play should really be a three word command: ‘just see it.’ There are so many plot twists that even loosely describing the story would be treading on dangerous ground. Of course the acting was good, of course the dialogue was good, and the plot…well, it was directed by JK Rowling, so enough said.
However, a noticeable aspect of The Cursed Child (that doesn’t offer up too many spoilers) is the incredible stage craft that sets it apart from even the most extravagant West End plays.
I’m not a theatre snob, so I’m happy to go to an am-dram performance in the back room of a pub where the only prop is a wooden chair. In fact, it is really appealing when a director and cast try to make use of their limited budget and staging.
Part of the beauty of theatre, which makes it far more interesting than cinema, is there’s no CGI, camera tricks, or green screen to fall back on. In a performance of the Railway Children the actors sat on boxes and lurched back and forth to create the image of a train journey; in Sherlock Holmes, coconuts sufficed for horse hooves; and in the National Theatre’s War Horse, life-sized puppets brought the animals to life.
With The Cursed Child, however, the special effects were so good I thought I was watching it on the big screen. So much so I almost forgot to clap the actors at the end. Far from losing the theatrical touch, it just proved, as one critic said ‘how much British theatre continues to be the best in the field.’ The producers took the raw element of theatre and manipulated and stretched it into new and exciting shapes.
The problem with a theatrical adaptation, when I’m already deeply invested in the story, is it needs to be perfectly how I imagined it. With Harry Potter, almost 15 years of commitment to the series meant that I had high expectations of the play. How were they going to do the magic on stage? I didn’t want it to be like Wicked. The magic in that borders on tacky, and it is too full on and flash to be clever or spectacular.
The Cursed Child’s special effects, however, were simply mind-blowing. I thought I just paid to see a play, but I got a magic show as well. Every ingenious bit of magic that’s so wonderfully rendered in the Potter films is presented in almost exactly the same way on stage. Levitation, apparition, ‘engorgio’…nothing was left out because it was too difficult.
I was sitting in the balcony, so had a view of the front and back of the stage. However, I didn’t see a single trap door, a single character swap, or a single stage hand hastily swapping one object for another. It was quite simply magic, and if someone had told me a real wizard had charmed the play I wouldn’t be surprised.
I even felt some scenes were put in just to give the director an excuse to use magic tricks. They knew what fans of Harry Potter wanted and they delivered it spectacularly.
Once upon a time, I was happy with a rabbit pulled out of a hat. Then I read the Philosopher’s Stone and my boundless child’s imagination believed there was more to magic than just tricks of the eye. Then I went to see The Cursed Child – and to be honest, I still believe wizards exist.
Photograph: Florianne Humphrey
