Some Thing New review: ‘frustrating’

SomeThingNew450x300

By Simon Fearn

Some Thing New is a very frustrating play. Its raison d’être appears to be a send up of the pretentious posturing of would-be artists, yet in doing so it also manages to become deeply pretentious itself. An original script by Anna Jeary and Alissa Cooper, yesterday’s three productions are previews to gather audience feedback before the production’s Edinburgh Fringe debut. The play’s experimental format and use of audience participation would seem to be ideal for the Fringe, yet I couldn’t help feeling that on occasion it fell a bit flat.

After being handed what must have been the most hipster, handwritten programme I have ever had the pleasure to peruse, the audience was welcomed into a tiny room in Chad’s, which had been transformed into a bohemian hovel. It took a while for me to realise that the actors were actually in character as they handed out Sharpies and pebbles, which was testament to the naturalistic acting which was more or less maintained throughout the production. By contrast, the play’s exposition was rather clunky, featuring a lengthy history of art monologue by smug lecturer Edward (Hamish Clayton), complete with PowerPoint, followed by a slightly contrived introduction of all the other arty characters.

I would be lying if I said there weren’t some fantastic moments.  Clayton was fabulous at delivering very silly lines, my favourites being ‘a heart of stone is but a sculpture’ and ‘you don’t write what you know, you write what you know’. The cast also worked very well together as an ensemble, and my eyes were often drawn from the central action to take in the fabulous reactions of Adam Simpson as Ally and Zoe Coxon as Kat. The highlight of the play had to be realising halfway through a discussion about poetry that on the other side of the stage a semi-naked Polly Narrett as Arianna was being steamily painted by Clayton.

Much of the humour was on point, but structurally the play was a bit of a mess. It essentially consisted of a monologue apiece for each character, loosely held together by audience participation and improvisation. The play is very aware of this issue, with one of the characters commenting that ‘nothing fits together in any tangibly coherent way’, which is bound to encourage appreciative comments of ‘so meta darling!’ in Edinburgh. But this doesn’t quite excuse the fact that character development seemed like an afterthought amidst the postmodernist set up. This led to Simpson’s character being purely limited to sarcastic comments until the end of the play, and a plot strand about Coxon’s ex-girlfriend being unceremoniously abandoned.

Audience participation can work very well, but rather than breaking the fourth wall this production dragged the audience onto the stage and subjected them to as much scrutiny as the cast, in my case quite literally. Your faithful reviewer’s lack of knowledge about pre-Raphaelite artists and Dylan Thomas poems was made embarrassingly evident to the rest of the audience as I was invited to join the cast in a game of ‘categories’. Yes, it was rather funny, but after the play the cast told me I was picked because I looked like the most nervous member of the audience, which could lead to a feeling of victimisation in Edinburgh if they manage to find people more nervous than me (believe me, they do exist!)

One of the key problems of this production is that it is not designed to be an inclusive play. A lot of the humour is actually aimed at the sort of arty types the production is meant to be parodying. I caught the well timed Lear reference, but later discovered from the audience that a Byron quotation had gone straight over my head.

In the lengthy questionnaire attached to the programme, one of the questions was a cheekily ironic ‘how did it make you feel’. On serious reflection, I didn’t really feel anything. The characters, whilst entertaining and comedic, were too slight to care about, and the play’s experimentation stopped just short of being gimmicky.

Photo: Alissa Cooper