Eni Aluko’s own goal: Wright argument, wrong man

By Erica Murphy-Hogg

Eni Aluko has once again reopened her dispute with Ian Wright, nearly a year after the first episode. Having previously apologised for naming Wright in a BBC Radio 4 Woman’s Hour discussion about access in women’s football punditry, Aluko has now doubled down. Speaking on the 90s Baby Show podcast last week, she accused Wright of failing to champion her during a difficult professional period. She contrasted his silence over ITV’s decision regarding her role with his vocal backing of Gary Lineker during the BBC impartiality row in 2023. 

Aluko here is reiterating her previous argument that male pundits are “blocking” positions in the women’s game that should operate as pathways for former female players. On Woman’s Hour, she stated there are only “a finite amount of opportunities for women” and warned Wright should be conscious of “how much he’s doing in the women’s game”. Her latest intervention homed in on how Wright individually is limiting the number of such on-air positions. She argued that Wright and Nedum Onuoha taking pundit roles at the 2025 Women’s Euros exemplified men occupying potential female vacancies, while she and experienced pundit Fara Williams stood in the stands. 

Male pundits are “blocking” positions in the women’s game that should operate as pathways for former female players

Despite popular bashing of Aluko it is important to acknowledge Aluko’s credibility as a former Lioness with 105 caps to her name and a legacy of opposing racism and sexism in football. She was also the first woman to appear as a pundit on Match of the Day in 2014. It is also necessary to highlight that, irrespective of the nature of Aluko’s comments, the barrage of online hate she has faced is completely unjustified and foregrounds the dangers of today’s cancel culture on social media. Thus, I aim to show how critiquing her approach is valid but vilifying her as an individual is not. 

I believe, unlike some, there is substance to her broader structural concern, and I would argue that Wright would most likely agree. She notes how the highest-profile domestic and international men’s fixtures remain dominated by established male commentators such as Alan Shearer, Rio Ferdinand and Micah Richards. All while the women’s game appears a ‘free-for-all’ in terms of coverage. Therefore, the foundations of Aluko’s assertion are somewhat accurate and underscore that diversity within football remains far from resolved. However, it would be wrong to state there hasn’t been any progress in the media landscape, as there has been greater female representation in the men’s game in the following years. This is most clearly shown by two women anchors fronting Match of the Day and former Arsenal player and Lioness, Alex Scott presenting BBC’s Saturday flagship show, Football Focus. 

“It would be wrong to state there hasn’t been any progress in the media landscape”

Additionally, Aluko’s delivery doesn’t help the legitimacy of her case. By centring Wright, one of the most visible and admired male advocates for the women’s game, the conversation seems oriented around individual grievance. This is particularly relevant given, ITV last year prioritised Wright’s punditry for women’s games over Aluko’s. Aluko articulates her frustration with Wright by suggesting she had expected him to adhere to the idea that “black people at the highest levels need to strategise”. On the surface, the notion of individuals with shared experiences empowering one another appears reasonable. However, on closer examination, it is difficult to identify any concrete wrongdoing on Wright’s part in this respect. 

It is more than possible for allies to support structural change without being obliged to promote specific colleagues. Her surprise at Wright’s supposed lack of backing indicates that her issue is more directed at him for superseding her at ITV than at the broader football issue she conflates with her argument. 

Interestingly, Wright responded to Aluko last April by saying he was “very disappointed” with the entire affair. He added that he could not accept her apology, though he stressed that he wished to “move on”. While Wright has remained quiet on her latest remarks, Aluko revealed last week on TalkSport radio that she had yet to personally communicate with him since the controversy. This cements Wright’s sustained effort to distance himself from Aluko. 

Ultimately, Aluko’s mistake may not lie in raising the issue of fair opportunity, but in choosing the wrong battleground. Wright has consistently empowered women’s football and treated it with the same seriousness as the men’s game unlike other male counterparts. Her personalisation of a structural debate and repeated confrontations with him are evidently eroding the legacy she has worked hard to build. The questions she has raised deserve serious discussion, but her confrontational tone has ultimately distracted from the broader issue of securing fair representation for female pundits in broadcasting. 

Image By jarmoluk via Pixabay