The Lib Dems’ proposal for a Department of Growth

By Vardan Umbreyan

Liberal Democrat Treasury Spokesperson and Deputy Leader Daisy Cooper MP unveiled a radical plan to ‘Get Britain Growing Again to end the cost living crisis’ during her speech on 11th of February. The Deputy Leader highlighted plans to replace the Treasury with new Departments for Growth and Public Expenditure. 

Under the plan, the Department of Growth would assume responsibility for tax policy, fiscal rules and strategic national infrastructure, while the Department of Public Expenditure would oversee departmental budgets and spending control. The current Department of Business and Trade would be merged into the new Department of Growth, that is for ensuring that business and investment is aligned with nationalpriorities.  

Cooper argued that such a division mirrors institutional models in major economies including the United States, where fiscal responsibilities are divided between the Department of Treasury and Office of Management and Budget and Australia, where the duties are being implemented by the Department of Treasury and Department of Finance.  

Yet whilst this approach seems practically tested in the contemporary political structures, it may be questioned how the separation of the department will result in positive economic adaptability within a decreased workforce and civil service presence. 

Beyond outlining broad responsibilities, the Liberal Democrats have yet to provide a detailed functioning explanation about how coordination between the two new departments would be organized in practice

While there is no structural description regarding the practicality of the reform from party members, Daisy Cooper within her speech mentioned that the new Department of Growth would be based in Birmingham, the second largest city in the UK which according to MP would help narrow the ‘the yawning gap between the UK’s capital city and every other city and all other parts in the UK’. 

Regarding the workforce, the MP mentioned there will be no decrease among workforce occupation, instead it is to propose the involvement of new employers. While the Lib Dems have argued the proposal would be a reform for the benefit of the country, the Treasury Spokesperson challenged the existing government majority with her speech mentioning that ‘we don’t need to get rid of this anti-growth Chancellor, we need to get rid of the anti-growth Treasury.’   

It is still yet to be confirmed how the party itself will formulate it in their election manifesto. Considering the Lib Dem 2024 manifesto, Matthew Bowles from Prosperity Institute argued that there was sufficient rhetoric with insufficient practically implementable economic policies.

It is uncertain how the party will benefit from this policy reform, until the implementation process would be finalized

However, one thing is evident: the existing 72 seats that the party has, are not primarily secured on the back of a transformative macroeconomic programme.   

The reform itself upholds fundamental questions which are still undecided; would a new Office of Budget and Management report to the Prime Minister? Or would a new spending minister effectively become a second chancellor in all but name? 

Further, there is a sense of déjà vu in the proposal, which sounds similar to the rationale behind the Department of Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, renamed by Boris Johnson in 2021, which, regardingto reports from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) struggled to produce a sustained regional convergence. Structural renaming and relocation, history suggests, do not automatically translate into measurable economic transformation.  

While the conceptual plan aims to protect the future economic independence of the country, there are fundamental practical questions which still need to be finalized and framed from the party, which might be decisive towards the representation percentage in the future parliamentary elections. 

Image: House of Commons via Creative Commons