Is gym culture making us lonelier?
By Erica Murphy-Hogg
In Durham, exercise is unavoidable. Someone is always in a DU kit, always mid-run, always on their way to the gym. The university prides itself on being one of the sportiest in the country, and it shows. What’s less obvious is how much of that movement now happens in isolation.
Across Britain, team sport appears to be quietly losing ground to the gym. Wellness influencing and personalised fitness routines have become the dominant way that young people engage with exercise. Sport, once rooted in collective commitment, has been replaced by something more private and individual. The question is not whether students are active, but whether they are still playing together.
The gym offers an easier alternative. There are no trials, no teams to commit to, and no fear of letting others down. You can go whenever you want and speak to no-one if you so choose. For a post-pandemic generation that is frankly less accustomed to putting itself out there, this autonomy is deeply appealing. Team sport demands more than physical effort; it requires vulnerability: turning up as a beginner, being visibly bad before you improve, and navigating group dynamics. Those are skills that take confidence and practice.
At Durham, this diversion from sport is less immediately obvious. The university is consistently ranked among the top British universities for sport and was named Sports University of the Year in The Times and Sunday Times Good University Guide 2023. International-level athletes compete for Durham teams, including England women’s hockey players and rowers. With so many students visibly athletic, it can feel as though team sport is thriving.
For a post-pandemic generation that is frankly less accustomed to putting itself out there, this autonomy is deeply appealing
Yet Durham’s unique demographics arguably intensify the shift rather than counter it. Around 39.1% of Durham students are privately educated, compared to the national average of roughly 6%. This is not suggesting that sport is a simple class issue, but in an environment where such a large proportion of students arrive having trained intensively from a young age with access to elite coaching, it is unsurprising that others feel intimidated. Excellence becomes the assumed baseline. I know capable athletes at Durham whose exclusion from DU teams seems to be tied less to ability than to stereotype. Consequently, the gym feels safer: there is little direct judgment and no assumption that you simply wouldn’t fit in.
However, gym culture has recently faced broader criticism as people reflect on the limitations of relying solely on the gym. In one of Kareem Rahma’s Subway Takes videos, Louis Theroux remarked on the absurdity of a culture in which we now pay to simply move our bodies. Theroux illuminates how movement has been detached from everyday life and relocated into controlled spaces where mirrors and metrics are key. Progress is measurable, but often solitary. Fitness becomes something to curate rather than experience.
But Durham students are not out of hope. The college sports system offers a rare middle ground: competitive enough to be engaging but low stakes enough to be welcoming. College teams allow students to relearn the skills that they once had or to try something entirely new, without the pressure of elite performance. This year, my housemate and I picked up college hockey and college padel to meet people and discover joy in different types of movement. We’ve run half marathons and have trained seriously yet still felt something was missing. Playing team sport again, being bad at something and laughing throughout training was refreshing in a way that no solo gym session ever is.
Team sport offers what the gym cannot: shared purpose. It develops communication, resilience, cooperation, and confidence. These qualities extend far beyond the pitch. In a time when many young people lack meaningful community, these benefits matter.
Team sport offers what the gym cannot: shared purpose
I want to reiterate that any movement is good movement, and that the gym will always have its place. But if fitness becomes purely individual, we risk mistaking movement for meaning. Durham has the structures to resist this shift. The challenge is getting young people back into a team environment.
Image Credit: Matti Blume

