A game of two halves: are Manchester United’s reported job cuts justified?
By Tommy Price and Erica Murphy-Hogg
In a feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we asked Deputy Sport Editor Tommy Price and Sport Contributor Erica Murphy-Hogg whether Manchester United’s reported job cuts are justified?
Yes: Tommy Price
It is no secret that Manchester United are in a slumber both on and off the pitch. The club sits 14th in the Premier League – a title they haven’t won since 2013; 3rd in the Europa League group – a tournament that feels all too familiar for this team; and they have just been knocked out of the FA Cup in the fifth round – a cup that they currently hold, but won’t for much longer.
To make matters worse, they find themselves in a dire economic situation – a reflection of extremely poor performances by the players in recent years, and even worse ownership by the Glazers who have well and truly run the club and Theatre of Dreams into the ground (we’ve all seen the videos of England’s fourth tallest waterfall at Old Trafford).
There are those that might argue that the early years of Glazer rule were a success, with 2006-13 being a very successful period for the club. Behind the scenes, the club was being set up for ruin. According to the Financial Times, “in the three years to 2024, United made losses totalling more than 300m, making them the second most lossmaking club in the English Premier League after Chelsea”.
Something needs to change, with the club now very much in danger of failing to comply with the Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules and unfortunately, as hard as this is to argue, both structural and operational changes seem necessary – it’s a painful reality that Sir Jim Ratcliffe is having to now deal with.
Something needs to change, with the club now very much in danger of failing to comply with the Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules
Streamlining the workforce has therefore been argued by those at the top to be part of a wider strategy to restore financial health and ensure compliance with PSR, which, if breached, could result in severe penalties such as transfer restrictions or even points deductions.
Furthermore, these changes and job cuts are not simply about reducing costs; they are about restructuring the club to operate in a more modern and sustainable way. Manchester United’s outdated infrastructure – both physically and operationally – has long been a point of criticism. From the crumbling state of Old Trafford to an overcomplicated and perhaps excessive commercial department, redundancies in certain areas will allow for reinvestment into the core elements that truly matter for a football club: squad development, stadium renovation and footballing success.
The glory days seem a distant memory, and unless this drastic action is taken, the decline will only continue.
No: Erica Murphy-Hogg
While the Red Devils’ hopes of a consecutive FA Cup win crashed and burned, United’s workforce also took a major blow on home turf.
Having already suffered 250 redundancies announced last year, staff discovered that the club faces further budgeting cuts. This fresh wave of job losses will further erode United’s ties to its local community as the club struggles to recover from the deep-tissue damage incurred during the Glazer family’s reign. While Man United has one of, if not the, largest workforce of all Premier League clubs, the very nature in which this decision was delivered to staff embodies the breakdown and culture shift of the once great ‘Man U’ over the past five years.
Loyal staff only discovered the shocking number of staff being shown the red card via email after a meeting where United’s chief executive, Omar Berrada, outlined co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s ‘transformation policy’. Staff are rightly angry because this search for a stable future only targets those at the bottom of the pay scale. Is it really ‘sustainable’ for United to have paid out £14.5m for the exits of their former manager and sporting director? Bad results, poor player purchases and high-level financial missteps – such as signing a long lease on a club HQ in Knighstbridge(!) – point to leadership unaware that Man Utd is no longer the global superbrand it once was.
Compared to the heavy self-inflicted financial losses United has repeatedly suffered, the savings from these job cuts appear trivial
Ratcliffe claims he’s Manchester through and through. So far, he’s hiked ticket prices for loyal fans, sanctioned mass redundancies and limited lunches for staff. I’m not sure the people living close to Old Trafford, who rely on the club for employment and entertainment, will feel Jim’s a true Red as his chauffeur cruises past their suburban semis.
The club’s grandiose gestures of employing big names and new personnel have backfired entirely, as shown by Dan Ashworth’s five-month stint as sporting director. Compared to the heavy self-inflicted financial losses United has repeatedly suffered, the savings from these job cuts appear trivial.
Do we trust that Ratcliffe isn’t making a grave error ridding the club of one of its enduring strengths: devoted employees who show up in every way for Manchester United? Football is not any old business. It’s ruled by heart as well as head. Sir Jim would do well to remember that as he’s driven through the streets of Trafford.
Image: André Zahn via Wikimedia Commons

