CTE: no longer the great unknown

By Tommy Price

In recent weeks, one of the most pressing sporting issues appears to have finally been settled. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) announced that a ‘cause-and-effect’ relationship between repeated blows to the head sustained in sport and chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) has been scientifically proven.

CTE is an aggressive neurodegenerative disease, first discovered in the brain of NFL Hall of Famer, Mike Webster. Its symptoms include memory loss, mood swings and difficulty thinking, similar to that of Alzheimer’s disease.

For many, the NIH’s breakthrough discovery may not seem like news. The aggressive brain disease has received extensive media attention for years due to its close relation to contact sport athletes, particularly American football players. According to The New York Times, CTE “has been found in the brains of more than 320 former NFL players”. One could easily assume that a scientifically proven link between repeated head-impacts in sport and the disease had long been established. The reality is quite the opposite.

Until very recently, CTE and its connection to brain injuries had been extremely misunderstood and under-recognised by scientists and sporting bodies alike. Take the Concussion in Sport Group (CISG), perhaps the most influential organization regarding guidance on head injuries in sports. In their last consensus statement in 2017, they stated: “the notion that repeated concussion or subconcussive impacts cause CTE remains unknown” and requires “more research”.

Governing bodies such as FIFA and World Rugby use the CISG’s advice to shape their rules and regulations on head injuries. With the causal link between head impacts and CTE in athletes yet to be officially recognised by the CISG, sporting bodies have attempted to dissociate themselves from the disease and have not yet addressed the issue of CTE in their athletes.

Drastic changes are expected to be made at all levels of contact sport

This is something organisations such as Headway and Head for Change have been campaigning endlessly to change. They, along with many other people, are not happy with the stance sporting bodies such as FIFA have taken, questioning the morality of some of these associations.

The Interim Chief Executive of Headway, Luke Griggs, thinks that “Football’s stubbornness to adapt is putting the short and long-term health of players at risk and change can no longer be resisted at the highest level of the sport”.

So what now? The governing bodies of all the major contact sports cannot simply ignore the latest news on CTE, and nor can the CISG. The research they were looking for is now here, and the evidence is clear. With no choice but to acknowledge the new findings, drastic changes are expected to be made at all levels of contact sports, from professional to grassroots.

For many students at “Britain’s Number 1 Team Sport University”, the recent breakthrough will have a huge impact. Contact sports make up a large majority of the 18 sports that Durham University offers to its students. The way in which students both train and compete is likely to change significantly in the coming years. However, what these reforms will look like and when they will come into force is hard to predict.

In light of the NIH’s latest findings, sporting bodies will now be facing a huge range of complexities about how to deal with brain injuries in their athletes. Should heading be entirely eradicated from football? Should tackling be banned in rugby? Should fighting be removed from ice hockey? These are the types of issues that could take years to be resolved and even longer be put into place.

Nevertheless, with the risk of CTE now very much at play, fans and players alike should prepare for some rigorous changes.

Image: Chris Smallwood via Flickr