Can TV adaptations of video games be successful?

By Eunice Wu

Hailed as one of the best video games of all time, Naughty Dog’s The Last of Us was actually my first foray into gaming culture. Like any significant piece of popular culture, Hollywood wants a bite of it. HBO’s ten-episode TV show adaptation of the game has just released its trailer, and it’s been largely praised by the Internet for its faithfulness to the original narrative. How much faith should we actually put into this series? How successfully can video games be adapted into on-screen narratives?

The Last of Us tells a poignant story of humanity and survival through stellar cinematography, stunning post-apocalyptic world design and a compelling storyline. With a remake that just came out recently, the game’s impressive graphics have already reached the ceiling of realism. Playing the game essentially feels like watching a movie. Thus, visually, the TV show offers nothing ground-breaking.

A common view is that HBO’s show will allow non-gamers to experience the story of The Last of Us. This begs the question of what the producers truly want to achieve with this show: are you catering to fans of the game or the general public? Perhaps striking an equilibrium would be the most rational approach. Considering the game’s writer and creative director is credited in the show’s trailer, we should at least be relieved that HBO will not butcher this story due to insufficient source material. As a fan who played the game, I would love to see the show respect the original without being an exact replica. For example, depicting the story through Ellie’s perspective more and exploring themes of morality that extend beyond the game’s ending. 

Video games are a mixed bag, so the case may be that not every on-screen adaptation of a video game is well-received

Video games are a mixed bag, so the case may be that not every on-screen adaptation of a video game is well-received. One example is the Uncharted movie which came out earlier this year. As much as I love Tom Holland, casting him as Nathan Drake was a bad decision. Nathan Drake is not your friendly neighbourhood treasure hunter, he’s a charming thief who proves to be a tough fighter. The movie’s lack of nuance waters it down to another Hollywood blockbuster action movie, which dismisses the video game series’ progressive improvement in character development and writing.  

On the flip side, Arcane proves to be a successful case, receiving critical acclaim from many who do not even play League of Legends. From music videos to cinematics, League of Legends has always produced top-notch content in terms of building lore. With Arcane available on streaming services, it became more accessible for the general public. In fact, the accessibility of the show’s story plays a big part in its success too. No prior knowledge of the game is needed to enjoy the show, in fact as a non-player I was positively shocked to realise that Jinx was a villain and that this was her origin story. With League of Legends being a nonlinear game, as opposed to something like The Last of Us where the player is guided through a predetermined path to complete the story, there is a lot more freedom with storytelling and worldbuilding in adaptations like Arcane.

Time for the final verdict: can on-screen adaptations of video games be successful? Well, it depends! Movies like Detective Pikachu seem to have their audience, but I am much too frightened by anthropomorphic animals with realistic fur to know if I am one of these fans. Ultimately, the quality of the product is influenced by a variety of factors, with the type of game it’s based on and the film’s direction playing pivotal roles. Needless to say, I am still waiting in anticipation for HBO’s series to drop so that I can navigate the heart-wrenching world of The Last of Us again.

Image: Sean Stone via Unsplash