Dynamic pricing: has live music become an exclusive experience for the wealthy?

By Erin Donnelly

Over this past year, the UK’s live music industry has hit a record-breaking profit of £6.1 billion. This has been fuelled largely by world-renowned artists, namely Beyonce, Coldplay, and of course Taylor Swift’s ‘Eras Tour’. However, despite this financial increase within the UK’s live music scene, and an apparent shared appetite for these experiences amongst the general public, a bigger question remains: is live music accessible for the many, or for the few?

Last month, ground-breaking news shocked the music world as the Gallagher brothers’ fifteen-year feud ended and Oasis’ long-awaited reunion was announced. Yet tears of joy soon descended into tears of frustrations as fans became victims of dynamic pricing – a practice fans had not expected the Mancunian legends to adopt. Dynamic pricing is essentially the adjustment of prices in response to changing market conditions, such as demand, and was adopted by Ticketmaster, increasing ticket prices to almost three timed their original value in response to the overwhelming demand for this once-in-a-lifetime reunion. Fans were left to queue all day long to only find that, if they were lucky enough to escape Ticketmaster’s riddles, the ticket prices stated in official statements had risen to extortionate prices. While standing tickets at Wembley Stadium, for example, were initially £150, fans were later greeted with the staggering prices of £355 and upwards. Even for Oasis fanatics, it is a bitter and heartbreaking pill to swallow. So, who do creative industries really care for? Their fans? Or do they favour those capable of affording extortionate prices to feed the industry’s capitalist greed?

Oasis came, rocked, and conquered Europe – they were a triumph of the British working class

In Oasis’ case, however, what provoked the large majority of their fans, including myself, was the irony of this ticketing fiasco. The self-proclaimed working-class Mancunian band were more than merely icons from the 1990s Britpop era. Oasis came, rocked, and conquered Europe – they were a triumph of the British working class. Born and bred in the industrial city of Manchester, living with their mum, Peggy, and older brother, Paul, in a council estate, they were underdogs in the big circus and glamour of the music industry. Yet, their simple desire to play pure rock and roll, cloaked in their notorious arrogance, and emerging from the nation’s old industrial heartland, earnt them the privilege of being figureheads for those “left behind”. After the legacies of the Thatcherite model in the North, her neoliberal reforms benefitting London at the expense of the North and further cemented by her successor John Major, Oasis were a stark proclamation that the North was not, and will never be, dead. 

In the ensuing backlash, the conversation about the Oasis reunion, dynamic pricing, and the live music industry quickly became a commentary about class and wealth. The Gallagher brothers were the working-class heroes of the Britpop era and now force their fans to fall victim to dynamic pricing, the irony of which is not lost. Political leaders too have criticised the set-up, with Prime Minister Keir Starmer stating it unfair to “price people out of the market” and, according to Mary Lou McDonald, Sinn Fein’s leader, an example of the band “throwing working class-fans under the bus”. If even musical artists from humble roots like the Gallagher brothers themselves can fall into the industry’s warped, capitalist, and self-indulgent tendencies, I fear where the future of live music ahead.

Even musical artists from humble roots like the Gallagher brothers themselves can fall into the industry’s warped, capitalist, and self-indulgent tendencies

Yet, in response to calls from fans and consumer lawyers alike to tackle this ticketing epidemic, Oasis have proved they have listened to and absorbed their fans’ dismay. The balloting process for their final two shows of the UK and Ireland tour, set to occur in over a years’ time at Wembley stadium, demonstrated how quick, easy, and truthful the ticketing process should and is meant to be. Fans do not have to be exploited for an artist’s negligence and greed and become mere victims of the exploitative system. 

In an age when dynamic pricing has become increasingly popular, polarised, and present, it is entirely down to musical artists to prevent live music from becoming an art form exclusively for the wealthy and privileged. Live music should not be regarded as a luxury for the few. It is an integral part of being human, enjoying the world around us, and embracing all stretches and bounds of culture.   

Image: Dariusz Grosa via Pexels