Was Barbie truly ‘snubbed’ in the 96th Academy Awards nominations?

By Erin Donnelly

In July 2023, the ‘Barbenheimer’ phenomenon significantly changed the film industry. However, for Barbie, record-breaking commercial success did not qualify for a clean-sweep of award nominations, with Greta Gerwig’s blockbuster reportedly being ‘snubbed’ by the Academy Awards. The idea that Gerwig and Margot Robbie were ‘robbed’ of nominations for Best Director and Best Actress has sparked widespread controversy, associated with female struggles within the patriarchal film industry. However, how far does their ‘snub’ prove a reflection of the film’s core message, serving as a satirical mirror to reality? Is it credible to suggest their ‘lack’ of nominations is an attack on feminism? Or, is this public outcry obscuring the truly remarkable achievements for women in this year’s nominations?

On the 23rd January, Barbie received an array of eight Oscar nominations, which ranged from Best Picture to Best Adapted Screenplay. However, it has been criticised that Gerwig and Robbie were overlooked – especially when the charismatic, girl-power duo were ‘responsible’ for the film’s commercial success. I admit, it was a shock when Gerwig failed to receive a nomination for Best Director, particularly as Barbie has proven to be the first (and only) billion-dollar blockbuster directed solely by a woman. However, it is important to remind ourselves both women were nominated in the respective categories for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Picture. Perhaps, then, having fixated upon Gerwig and Robbie, we have underplayed the wider accolade achievements for women in this year’s Academy Awards.

Having fixated upon Gerwig and Robbie, we have underplayed the wider accolade achievements for women in this year’s Academy Awards

America Ferrera earnt her first Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress, making history as one of the few Latinas to receive a nomination, alongside Rita Moren and Lupita Nyong’o. Ferrera plays Gloria, a Mattel employee, who rescued Barbies from indoctrination in the patriarchal ‘Ken mojo dojo casa house’, and delivered the film’s infamous monologue about the impossibility of being a woman. Her nomination is not merely a celebration of her talent, yet emblematic of the media’s improving shift in attitudes towards Latina performances, dismantling racial frontiers and stereotypes. Thus, the public’s reception to the nominations have evidently neglected the Academy Awards’ increased (although still limited) acknowledgement for diverse representation. Undoubtedly, Ferrara’s Barbie nomination proves a beacon for inspiration, marking the route for more Latina talent to be recognised, celebrated, and achieved.

Another significant achievement is the greater female Native American representation, which has previously suffered a long and fraught history of cultural appropriation. This year, Lily Gladstone became the first Native American nominated for Best Actress in Martin Scorsese’s Killers of the Flower Moon, and marks a significant moment in the Academy’s history. While the Oscar nominated actress admits this recognition is “all so long overdue”, the acknowledgement helps facilitate “shattering a lot of stereotypes people have about Indigenous women, particularly Native American women”. Such milestone achievements for women, representing over-looked and disadvantaged ethnic backgrounds, is worth commemorating, rather than being overshadowed by the general outcry towards Gerwig and Robbie’s ‘snub’.

Meanwhile, the fact Ryan Gosling was nominated Best Actor for Ken, when Robbie’s was not for Barbie, has contributed to the outrage. Individuals have claimed this proves the patriarchal consensus Gerwig’s film ardently criticised, as Gosling himself publicly voiced, claiming “there is no Ken without Barbie”. The discourse saw a political turn too, with Hillary Clinton critiquing the Academy and affirming that Gerwig and Robbie are “both so much more than Kenough”.

Is the industry only criticised as anti-feminist when white women are overlooked?

However, at closer analysis the backlash epitomises the façade of ‘White Feminism’, questioning how revolutionary the film’s message was. The fact that outrage over this ‘snub’ has eclipsed the celebration of this historic female achievement begs the question: is the industry only criticised as anti-feminist when white women are overlooked?

It is necessary to ask ourselves if this Barbie ‘controversy’ is manufactured for the wrong reasons. There seems to be a deep-rooted misconception that not awarding the block-buster directly equates to undermining the film’s feminist beliefs. Public outrage over Barbie detracts from the greater objective, which is to advocate for the inclusion of all women in the entertainment industry. Thus, it is more important now than ever to recognise such surface-level ‘White Feminist’ solidarity, and enlighten ourselves with radical, intersectional feminism, which can truly make a revolutionary difference.

Image: UKinUSA via Wikimedia Commons