To be or not to be a traitor: Is that really the question?
By Erin Donnelly
When asked if I was free any Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday evening this January, the automatic response was always “not until after I have seen The Traitors”. I was unashamedly addicted, absorbed, and attached
to the hit BBC One show. Whether it be the iconic scenes, memes, or Claudia Winkleman herself, an amalgamation of features underscored the show’s success and appeal to an entire nation. However, at what point is it right to romanticise media that essentially promotes deception as a means for success? What truly moulds a ‘good’ traitor? And, are traitors fundamentally bad people?
For those unaware of the show’s premise, it documents twenty-two strangers travelling together to a remote castle in the Scottish Highlands, where they discover their fate as either traitors or faithfuls. Unaware of how many traitors have been recruited, the faithful’s duty is to navigate and deduce who they believe to be a traitor following each day’s tasks, individual behaviours, and ‘theories’ spoken about. Inevitably, the day culminates at the round table, where the contestants vote who they personally feel vindicated to evict from the castle. Whoever receives the most votes ultimately retreats from the table, the castle, and reveals to the group their true identity.
Undoubtedly, the show forefronts how manipulation, intrigue, and deception can escape demonisation and be celebrated as a means for success in our society. While I will recall back to this later, the show was, and has always proven to be, an enjoyable and addictive watch. The desperation to discover who has been recruited as a traitor, murdered by the traitors at night, or what the next twist will be, attracted a national audience and exactly the quality-level entertainment viewers enjoyed. As viewers, we have the omniscient position of witnessing a group of people meet for the first time, navigate their lives in complete isolation from the outside world, and attempt to form a comradery with their fellow contestants.
How far should we value entertainment over promoting the true purpose and values of being a human being?
However, what struck me this year was the clear distinction between friendship groups and friendship cliques. This particular series presented an environment which, personally, proved how unpleasant the experience was if certain individuals failed to forge certain alliances. Kas, for example, a faithful from the beginning, was targeted from the show’s first moments, albeit due to his straightforward manner and occupation as a doctor. One incident at the round table saw Jake, one of the two victorious contestants, accuse Kas with an illogical theory that he was most certainly a traitor as he saves lives during the day, due to the nature of his job, arguing it only made sense that he “killed at night”. This vilification was a recurring theme across this series’ entirety and saw individuals, like Kas, ostracised, excluded from sitting with others at meals, and unable to converse with other contestants. All due to a false depiction immediately targeted upon him. This was the fundamental flaw of this series: the contestants prioritised attacking
others personally, rather than honing in on the logistics of this strategic game.
This brings me to question what truly constitutes a successful traitor. Harry from series two is most certainly the epitome of a ‘good traitor’. Undoubtedly, you do not want your name under speculation or spotlight. In turn, make life easier for yourself. Do not lie about your background, your occupation, or your character. It’s
important to present yourself as an open book, known to everyone, with no complications. Rather, play the game simply, being truthful, when necessary, to successfully underplay others, murder contestants nobody would expect you to be associated with, and place yourself in particular scenarios to appear as ‘the target’. For those who have watched series two, Harry successfully achieved this.
Yet, this begs the greater question: are traitors fundamentally bad people? While I would argue against this statement, believing their gestures to be instigated by a game rooted in the hunt for money and a national viewing, I question how far we should celebrate media that both embraces and idolises traits inherently against human nature. How far should we value entertainment over promoting the true purpose and values of being a human being? The media we construct, consume, and comment upon continue to shape our everyday beliefs, whether we recognise this or not. Therefore, it is entirely up to us to debate how far what we enjoy viewing is a representation of ourselves. While I adore the show, at some point I find myself stuck in a moral dilemma: Am I just as morally defiled as a traitor?
Image: Fluous via Wikimedia Commons

