Durham Union in Donor Controversy as Only 30% of Guest Speakers are Women

By Josh Eaton

Palatinate can reveal that only 30% of the guest speakers at Durham Union are women during the upcoming Epiphany Term cycle. The controversial debate society released their Epiphany term card, revealing the various speakers and events over the coming months.

Guests include former cabinet minister Ester Mcvey, Palestinian Ambassador Husan Zumlot and former Chairman of the 1922 Committee, Lord Brady.

This term at the Durham Union has been ‘supported by’ The Ian Mactaggart Programme, which provides generous sums to University groups of up to £1500 per term for the ‘promotion of free speech’, is an initiative by the controversial Free Speech Union (FSU). Founded in 2020 with the goal of ‘countering cancel culture’, the group has mainly championed culture war issues such as anti-trans activism, lockdown and vaccine scepticism and identity politics.

Similar FSU-backed initiatives in the past have come under criticism for being an ‘astro-turfed’ front for the group’s wider aims. In 2021, student members of the ‘Free Speech Youth Advisory Board’ claimed that they were censured if they disagreed with the group’s right-of-centre orthodoxy. “The group started with quite diverse viewpoints,” Nürnberg, an activist and committee member of her university debating society, told The Guardian. “But very quickly that got shut down”. Students were even told in a group chat that “The degree to which citizens of China or Hungary have fs [freedom of speech], I would argue, isn’t of paramount importance to this project”, The Guardian reported previously. 

The Free Speech Union responded to the claim that “The Free Speech Union is a non-partisan membership organisation that stands up for the speech rights of its members, regardless of their political views. Forty per cent of the 3,300+ cases we’ve taken on since the organisation was founded five years ago have been feminists who’ve got into trouble for defending sex-based women’s rights. We’ve also defended pro-Palestinian protestors, environmental activists and former Labour MPs. Indeed, one of Ed Miliband’s former advisors is on our Advisory Council. In light of this, trying to characterise the FSU as right-wing is absurd.”

Founded in 2020 with the goal of ‘countering cancel culture’, the Free Speech Union has mainly championed culture war issues such as anti-trans activism, lockdown and vaccine scepticism and identity politics.

“The Ian Mactaggart Programme offers small grants of up to £1,500 per term to more than two dozen organisations and we welcome applications from all pro-free speech student groups at Durham.”

Durham Union Society has been plagued with controversies over recent months, including breaching the Equality Act over physically inaccessible debate, hosting a political leader from right-wing populist party Reform UK, and hosting a heavily-protested debate regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict in which one protester was arrested. 

The Durham Union responded “DUS is welcoming a number of high profile female speakers this Epiphany Term, including former President of the Republic of Ireland, Dr. Mary McAleese, former Cabinet Minister Esther McVey and Baroness Hayter, a Labour peer. We also look forward to hosting our second annual all-female international women’s debate on feminist foreign policy.”.

Whilst the renovation work is underway at the Pemberton Building, home to Durham Union’s usual debate chamber, debates will be relocated to locations such as the Marriott Hotel, the Great Hall at University College (Castle) and the somewhat less glamorous Elvet Riverside. 

Image: Anoushka Mundey