American influence in the Premier League: a potential problem?

By Alexander Beer

These days, only three Premier League teams are under British ownership. Seven of the teams are owned by investors from different countries. Now, with The Friedkin Group’s takeover of Everton, half of the teams are now majority-owned by Americans. Americans don’t just own the small teams that fall in and out of the league, but four of the ‘big six’—Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal, and Chelsea. Let’s take a look at some of the concerns surrounding these American owners.

Relocating teams

Stan Kroenke, Arsenal’s owner, concerns me the most. His ownership of the Los Angeles Rams, an American Football team, caused massive controversy when he relocated the team from St. Louis to Los Angeles in 2015 because of stadium disputes and financial incentives. One year later, the San Diego Chargers were also moved to Los Angeles, seeking a larger market and better stadium. This trend is a huge problem in American sports. Since 1999, there have been 9 relocations in the National Football League (NFL), National Basketball Association (NBA) and Major League Baseball (MLB), one of which was from Canada to the US. They’ve all been about stadium/arena disputes and financial incentives. Ripping teams from their homes and fans would be a massive insult to the teams in the PL. I’ve heard it said that this couldn’t happen in the PL due to history, but some NFL teams are older than PL teams and are victims of forced relocation. Money can win over history with American owners — a huge concern for the PL.

International games

Shahid Khan, Fulham’s owner, also owns an NFL team, the Jacksonville Jaguars. Since 2013, the year after Khan’s takeover, the Jaguars have played in London. These games generate massive profits, with high ticket prices and merchandise sales in a new market. They are nice for UK-based American Football fans, most of whom can’t travel to the US to catch games. However, for the Premier League, this could cause some problems. These international games for the PL would be profitable. This past summer, Manchester United played a friendly in LA, filling almost 63,000 of the stadium’s 70,000 seats. That’s crazy attendance and merchandise sales for a friendly. Imagine the income for a regular game! However, unlike American Football, dozens of other countries have fantastic football leagues. Even the US has a league good enough to attract the likes of Messi and Suárez. The PL is better than most, so their tickets would sell internationally. Yet since other countries can get their football fix locally, moving PL games internationally would only detract from the games and experience in England.

Americans don’t just own the small teams that fall in and out of the league, but four of the ‘big six’

The draft

Logistically, the selection of players in the Premier League varies drastically from American sports. The NFL, NBA, and MLB use the draft, where teams select new-to-the-league players they want without the player having any say. In the NFL and NBA, these players mostly come out of college, as players aren’t allowed to be drafted at high school ages. However, the MLB draft could logistically work in the PL. Liverpool, the current season leader, is owned by Fenway Sports Group, which owns the Boston Red Sox and is named after their stadium. In the MLB, players are scouted at a high school age, or from a minor or international league, like in the PL. When drafted, players are legally obligated to play for the team that drafted them, vastly restricting the freedom of players, who are often young and inexperienced. Additionally, players cannot reject transfers without ‘no-trade clauses’, which are only used for superstars. This system would be disadvantageous to players compared to foreign leagues, like La Liga or the Bundesliga, likely keeping talent away. However, half the PL owners now are from a country with the draft, with many of those owners’ drafting players for their other teams. The draft makes money from TV rights and the hype around it, and gives owners more control, at the expense of players.

American money helps keep the Premier League in the green, and so far, the owners have not made any massive changes to the integrity of the game. However, their influence is showing—American celebrities are becoming more invested in the game, and football is becoming more popular in the US. Now that half the teams are American-controlled, there are reasons to be concerned, even if these changes would be hard to achieve.