A game of two halves: Luke Littler is the best 17-year-old male athlete of all time
By Joseph Saunder and Alexander Beer
In a feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we asked Sport Contributor Alexander Beer and Sport Editor Joseph Saunders whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: Luke Littler is the best 17-year-old male athlete of all time
Yes (Joseph Saunders)
This January, Luke ‘the nuke’ Littler claimed his first ever Darts World Championship title. The Warrington-born phenom has become a household name since his emergence onto the Professional Darts Corporation Tour, winning the Grand Slam, Premier League, and World Series Finals in his first year on tour in 2024, aged 16 at the time.
It is hard to overstate Littler’s achievements. Many would call him the best player in the world – as odds on favourite for the World Champions this month and rising to number two in the world rankings there is no luck involved. Littler is just this good. Only world number one Luke Humphries could hold a candle to him in 2024, but he was unable to match Littler in the first tournament of this year.
The Warrington-born phenom has become a household name, winning the Grand Slam, Premier League, and World Series Finals in his first year on tour in 2024, aged 16 at the time.
Lebron James was still playing college basketball at 17. Lamine Yamal only scored seven goals in 50 matches last season. Pele may have won a World Cup in 1958 at 17, but he was undoubtedly not the best player in the world at the time. Raymond Kopa was Real Madrid’s Ballon D’Or winning talisman and fellow Frenchman Just Fontaine scored 13 goals in that World Cup, a record to this day. No 17 year-old man comes close to Littler.
However, there are a handful of women who easily outgun Littler’s achievements. American swimmer Katie Ledecky had broken six world record across three events before she turned 18. She won Olympic gold in the 800m freestyle in 2012 aged 15. Alternatively, Nadia Comaneci scored gymnastics’ mythical first perfect ten when she was 14 at the 1976 Montreal Olympics, earning her a gold medal. The final serious mention is for Martina Hingis. The Swiss tennis player won three of the four Grand Slams in 1997 aged 16, remarkably reaching world number one earlier that year. All three demonstrated more athleticism and traditional sporting values than Littler has, such is the nature of darts.
No (Alexander Beer)
I’m not going to argue that Luke Littler is not extremely accomplished, especially at his age—it’s hard to deny that he’s one of the best darts players now. But Lebron James was a different kind of 17-year-old.
At 17 LeBron James’ conditioning was incredible, being 6’8 and 240 pounds, but moving with speed and agility
At seventeen years old, LeBron dominated basketball. When he was fourteen years old, he was 6’2 and made the All-USA First team, consisting of the best players in the nation, for the first of three times, twice being named the best of all. In the 2000s, almost all basketball players were American, meaning he was, for all intents and purposes, the best in the world. At 17 his conditioning was incredible, being 6’8 and 240 pounds, but moving with speed and agility. He played showcase games against much older players and won, vastly more difficult in a contact sport like basketball than darts.
He was “Ohio Mr. Basketball” and “The Chosen One” and graced the cover of America’s biggest sports magazine. He scored 28 points per game at 17 when most professional players can’t score 25, but was still dominant on defence, leading his team to undefeated seasons. His basketball IQ was pro-level. He scored 52 points in a single game once, TV stations sold pay-per-view LeBron games for $8 apiece, and his team had to move into a university stadium for his games. He lost two games from ages 14-18 and won over 75. Does Littler have that record?
LeBron at 17 also played football. He was named first-team all-state, as he was one of the best in Ohio. He was recruited to play on a Division 1 team after. Coaches, players, and commentators all state he would have made it professionally if he hadn’t pursued basketball. Littler only plays one sport, but LeBron’s mastery of two at seventeen proves his greatness.
Image: DARTS NOW via Wikimedia Commons

