Is the London Stock Exchange in an existential crisis?

By Ashutosh Desai

The UK stock market’s ranking as a global IPO venue has tumbled down to 20th place. The London Stock Exchange now trails Oman and Malaysia in IPO venue rankings. The London Stock Exchange has had one of its worst years since 2009, with outflow of £280bn in combined valuation. In total 88 companies have delisted or moved their listing from London, while the number of new listings is its lowest in 15 years. Key firms are quitting for the US and the EU.

Major factors cited by firms for moving to New York are better liquidity and a widening gap between the US and the UK’s valuations, while some have moved to EU countries because of Brexit. Senior bankers expect more listings to transfer to the US next year.

The New York Stock Exchange does not tax share sales and purchases, unlike the London Stock Exchange where the government charges 0.5% duty. The chief executive of Interactive Investor said that the scale of the exodus was “eye-popping” and added, “We are taxing the UK stock exchange out of existence.”

“We are taxing the UK stock exchange out of existence”

Richard Wilson, Chief Executive of Interactive Investor

Either be a part of large or growing markets such as the US, China or India – or be a low tax jurisdiction. London is neither, hence its role as a financial centre (especially in terms of listed equity valuations and volumes) is increasingly under stress though from a high base. Julia Hoggett, the head of the London Stock Exchange, said the UK shouldn’t be “taxing our own investors to invest in our own economy”. The strength of the London Stock Exchange has serious implications for people even if they do not directly invest or work for it. These listings matter because service industries like accounting, law, and pensions – revolve around them. Pension funds often invest in UK equities, weakening of the London Stock Exchange could impact retirement income. Finance services account for 10% of UK GDP and generate more than £90bn in tax, half of the NHS budget.

Earlier this year, the UK’s biggest company Shell warned that it would look at “all options” for its listing. Shell’s former chief executive Van Beurden admitted that Shell had considered moving its listing to the US. He told the Financial Times (FT) that Shell was valued at a 30% discount compared to its US rivals, and they want to narrow down the gap. Shell’s departure will be a hammering blow for London.

Since 1997 the number of companies listed in the UK has fallen by almost half. The UK market today is dominated by ‘old economy sectors’, things like oil and mining, whereas technology, media, and AI are simply missing. Travel giant TUI, delivery provider JustEat, and gambling company Flutter (owner of Paddy Power and Betfair) are a few of the major firms to leave the London Stock Exchange last year (2024).

If this exodus were to continue, small-cap firms ($300m – $2bn) could be wiped out from London by the end of this decade. Peel Hunt in its report said that if the current pace of acquisitions were to continue the Financial Times Stock Exchange’s small cap would cease to exist.

The government plans to bring in radical reforms in the pension system, hoping it will boost growth. It also wishes to merge 86 council pension schemes into a handful of large funds run by fund managers, which make up for £345bn in investments. In addition to government reforms regulators have signed off on the “biggest overhaul” of rules for listed companies on the London Stock Exchange, new regulations will allow company executives to make decisions without shareholder votes and provide companies with the option to adopt dual-class equity structure, which will give private equity and venture capital firms extra voting rights. Executives privately told FT these recent forms “have not yet moved the dial”.

Image: Gren via Wikimedia Commons