Why people are talking about Scottie Scheffler again

By Alexander Beer

Scottie Scheffler cruised to victory with ease in the recent PGA Championship, adding a third Major to the American’s shelf of trophies. His previous two both came from the Masters, the most prestigious tournament in Golf, and he lost by a single stroke at the 2022 US Open. His Masters were both won with ease, the first seeing him beat Rory McIlroy, recent Grand Slam winner, by three strokes, and the second seeing him win with a four-stroke lead over Ludwig Åberg, who many say has one of the best swings ever seen in Golf. Similarly, his Quail Hollow victory was with a magnificent five-stroke lead over exceptional players like Bryson DeChambeau. Many commentators and fans thought McIlroy would come off his Masters win and claim a victory at a course that’s been historically strong for him. But Scheffler didn’t care about this speculation and put in one of his best weekends ever. Now, everyone is starting to wonder how many more he can win.

Scheffler is young—he’s only been pro for just over six years, and has won three majors in that time. He’s big and powerful, but he has a low power percentage. He’s not the best putter, but Tiger Woods said that even when he has a bad putting day, he’s still in contention for wins—high praise from one of the all-time greats. Watching him reminds me of being a kid in 2011-2014, where I saw firsthand Rory McIlroy’s incredible run. They both have fantastic rotation, especially in the hips, though Scheffler’s unique “Scottie Shuffle” sets his swing apart from any other golfer on tour. Both have had many tournaments with rough Fridays and/or Saturdays, only to come back on Sundays.

Scheffler didn’t care about this speculation and put in one of his best weekends ever. Now, everyone is starting to wonder how many more he can win

Where I see the most similarities, though, is their approach game. For recent golf fans, having seen Rory’s rougher years from 2015 onwards, this may not be evident, but his recent Masters victory showed just how dominant some of his chips were, with incredibly tight gaps to hit through and small greens. Scheffler has a similar mastery of his approach game. However, Scheffler’s got something that McIlroy doesn’t—an excellent hole-by-hole strategy. Even McIlroy’s Masters victory saw him make mistakes on his plan, with the 13th hole swallowing a ball that should have been nowhere near the water. But Scheffler’s “Green-Zone” strategy makes sure that his missed shots put him in better positions, like longer putts over chip-ins that will run away. This is critical at tournaments with fast greens, like the Masters, as long puts are easier to control than fast-moving balls striking the green from the fairway or bunkers. Hence, how Scheffler won two dominating Masters before any other Major.

The reason I have spent so much time talking about Rory McIlroy in an article about Scheffler is that he serves as almost a dark mirror for Scheffler. Rory won a Grand Slam, and no one will take that away from him. He’s a world-class golfer and probably the best of his generation, but his results don’t reflect that. Over twenty years on tour and only five Majors is not reflective of his talent. Scheffler has the potential to have a very similar career (two of the same Major relatively closely, followed by the others in rapid succession and then fizzling out before a decade-long comeback). But if he can stand tall and be mentally strong, he could get in the double digits. His game may not look technically the best, but it works for him, and he acknowledges the gaps in his play. Recently, he has shifted to a new claw grip for short putts and is working with a new coach to tighten his weakness.

At the Charles Schwab Challenge, he looked to be suffering from some back pain, but still tightened it up over the weekend to have a top-five finish. He did not win the Challenge, but the mental and physical fortitude he showed in the last two rounds seriously impressed me. We’ve seen him come back from some pretty tough stuff, like his hand injury stemming from cooking and his arrest. For those reasons, I think he could win many more majors. If he tightens up his putting, which he is working on, I genuinely think he could win eight to ten. He’s got the approach game, the youth, and the mental strength. He is probably the best American golfer since Tiger, which is a bold claim. But he’s got as many majors as Jordan Spieth and has not suffered the fall-off that Spieth has. And while he may not have as many Majors as Phil Mickelson, he’s a more complete and less risky golfer and has plenty of time to catch up. And I believe he will.

Image: Titleist via Wikimedia Commons