Corbyn’s Vision for a Collective Europe
By Will Fremont-Barnes
During quieter moments on the campaign trail, David Cameron surely must reflect on the irony that the European Union referendum, the promise of which helped him secure a second term in 10 Downing Street, has united the opposition whilst bringing his government to its knees. The Conservative Party is in the midst of its latest meltdown over Europe. By contrast, for all the talk of disunity in the shadow cabinet and on the backbenches since Jeremy Corbyn became Labour leader in September, the party’s stance on Europe has been clear: Britain is safer, stronger and more prosperous because of its EU membership.
Corbyn is something of a reluctant convert to the European project. Many people of Corbyn’s political persuasion react to the EU with the hysteria that characterises the Eurosceptic right, objecting instead on the grounds that it is essentially a capitalist plot to undermine workers. Yet with problematic internal debates to overcome – thorny issues such as the renewal of Trident and the re-selection process of incumbent MPs – ahead of the next general election, Corbyn has prioritised party unity by supporting the campaign to remain in the EU.
However, as he stressed this morning in a keynote speech, his post-referendum vision is starkly different from ‘pro-EU’ Conservative campaigners. Indeed, Corbyn’s support for staying in the EU seems driven by his concern that the Tory government would abandon huge swathes of environmental regulation and workers’ rights if they are no longer enforced by Brussels. Should Britain vote to leave on 23rd June, Corbyn pointed out, “it wouldn’t be a Labour government negotiating a better settlement for working people”, but a Tory government “quite possibly led by Boris Johnson and backed by Nigel Farage”. The result? “A free market free-for-all shorn of rights and protections.”
Corbyn dedicated much of his speech to pointing to the need for fundamental reform within the EU, criticising its “lack of democratic accountability” and its attempts to “deregulate public services”. Unsurprisingly, just as he has spent his parliamentary career putting forward a socialist case for Britain, he outlined a socialist vision for Europe, albeit one that did not bear resemblance to the EU as it is today; as such, it made for a rather strange speech. “By working together across our continent”, he said, “we can develop our economies, protect social and human rights, tackle climate change, and clamp down on tax dodgers.”
The environment, a peripheral issue so far, will feature more prominently if Corbyn’s first speech sets the tone for Labour’s campaign. Environmental concern lay at the heart of his argument: “climate change is the greatest threat that humanity faces this century, and no country can tackle it alone.” Just as Western European countries sought political and economic union in the aftermath of World War II, to prevent the re-emergence of continental conflict, fascism and communism, Corbyn indicated that similar action would be required to face what he perceives as a common deadly threat. “Polluted air doesn’t respect national borders”, Corbyn quipped as he emphasised the need for collective action on the environment.
That need for collective action extends to Corbyn’s view of labour alliances. He urged workers to make “common cause across national borders”, and recognised that it was the Tory government, not the EU, that had been a major stumbling block in this regard. Referring to the steel crisis as a “global problem”, Corbyn nevertheless dismissed the argument made by Vote Leave campaigners that the EU was responsible for the industry’s recent struggles. If the government had not blocked the EU’s coordinated efforts to impose tariffs on Chinese steel, Corbyn argued, the British industry would not be underperforming, nor, therefore, would jobs have been outsourced. This was a rare occasion on which Corbyn engaged with his opponents’ arguments.
The impact of migration, one of the key issues highlighted by Eurosceptics, received remarkably little attention. When Corbyn did speak about migration, it was in positive terms. “Free movement has created opportunities for British people”, he insisted, pointing to the contribution of immigrants to public services, and the millions of Britons who benefit by living on the continent. His brief acknowledgement of the drawbacks of immigration focused on the “exploitation of migrant labour to undercut wages” rather than on housing shortages or cultural impact. Arguments about remaining in the EU whilst recognising the need to manage immigration levels will be left to others during the campaign. On the issue of free movement, and the benefits it brings to Britain, Corbyn was simply preaching to the converted.
The Conservatives are not the only major party that wants to abandon the status quo in Brussels. “Europe needs to change”, Corbyn declared: “but that change can only come from working with our allies in the EU.” Like many voters in this referendum, Corbyn seems to favour the addition of a third choice accompanying Remain and Leave: Remain, but. Corbyn’s preference is for Britain to remain, but only in the event that a more progressive EU emerges, involving closer cooperation on trade, environmental regulation and social policy. For Eurosceptics, who bemoan the cooperation that exists already, this is an intolerable march towards ever closer union in which Westminster cedes yet more power to Brussels.
Corbyn’s encouragement to Labour members was to vote for a progressive vision of the EU rather than the current reality. Whether that encouragement will gain traction with the wider public remains to be seen. Nevertheless, Corbyn’s speech, despite its unconvincing tone and delivery, was well received by his audience. What the prime minister would give for the same level of party unity on Europe.
Photograph by DonkeyHotey via Flickr
