The Gerrard Conundrum: what next for Captain Fantastic?

By Will Fremont-Barnes

 

The man whose face adorned the match programme was conspicuous by his absence at Anfield on Saturday. Steven Gerrard, celebrating the sixteenth anniversary of his Liverpool debut, had to wait 75 before entering the action, brought off the bench as his side struggled for a breakthrough against well-organised opponents. Stoke City, who had chances of their own to grab all three points through Bojan and Mame Biram Diouf, were eventually beaten, with Glen Johnson putting his head in harm’s way to nod home.

Steven Gerrard

Yet the headlines the next morning were not about Johnson’s bravery, nor did they reflect much on Liverpool’s first home league win for nearly two months. Instead they were about Brendan Rodgers’s decision to leave his captain on the bench. There was, Rodgers insisted afterwards, no truth in stories about a potential rift between captain and manager, explaining that it was merely the result of a rotation policy that would affect all players with games coming thick and fast. Put in those terms, it seems eminently sensible management to rest a 34-year-old whose contribution will be more valuable when tougher opponents come to Anfield later in the season.

Gerrard was equally diplomatic about the issue, denouncing rumours about his souring relationship with Rodgers via Instagram. Unlike other high-profile English players of his generation, he hardly has history of falling out with managers, and it is unlikely that missing out on a starting spot in the league for the first time since New Year’s Day, when he was injured, would be enough to spark a row with Rodgers.

It is the timing of this episode that causes speculation. If Liverpool were winning games with the same regularity that they were last season, sweeping all before them on an incredible title challenge, and Gerrard was performing at the same incredibly high levels, then there would be no issue. As it is, Liverpool have suffered a hangover from throwing away the league in May, and their captain and talisman is finally beginning to look his age having appeared indefatigable for so long.

Gerrard effectively admitted that he would have to manage his body more carefully when he retired from international duty, withdrawing himself from England selection after the World Cup in order to focus his efforts on Liverpool. Although it was apparent that he still deserved his place in England’s midfield on merit during the World Cup, even if he and club-mate Jordan Henderson could have done with protection from a third midfielder in the centre, perhaps Gerrard predicted his own decline better than the rest of us.

He has been indignant that there has been no such loss of form. When he scored the opening goal in the Merseyside derby in September, Gerrard cupped a hand to his ear in order to mock his critics. Scoring a free-kick against Everton does not constitute evidence that the Gerrard of ten years ago, who spearheaded Liverpool’s Champions League triumph in Istanbul, is back. Gerrard will be able to strike a dead ball with the same accuracy when he is 64.

Gerrard’s expiring contract is likely to be at play here. He issued a stark warning last month that he could yet leave the club, very much putting the ball in Liverpool’s court by stating that his future lay in their hands. Maybe Gerrard is seriously contemplating a move elsewhere when his contract runs out in the summer, buoyed by the revival Frank Lampard has enjoyed at Manchester City, but it smacked of a classic negotiating tactic over his new deal. Rodgers, by the same token, could have been sending an equally clear message by leaving Gerrard on the bench, reminding him that nobody is indispensable.

In the event of a rift between Gerrard and Rodgers, there would be only one winner in the fans’ eyes. Liverpool supporters sing their manager’s name, but not with the same enthusiasm or volume with which they serenaded two of his predecessors, Kenny Dalglish and Rafa Benitez. Roy Hodgson did not last long enough for recognition of any kind from the Kop.

Indeed, the fans who criticised Rodgers’s appointment in the first place, and then condemned him at every turn as he tried to rebuild from scratch in his first season, have begun to re-emerge, crawling out from the woodwork as Liverpool’s form has dipped since the summer. The fact is that Rodgers did not cost Liverpool the title last season with his overly attacking approach, because without that they would not have been in a position to slip up against Chelsea or surrender a three-goal lead at Selhurst Park. Whilst he cannot survive off one good season forever, Rodgers deserves huge credit for the way he got Liverpool playing.

Yet Rodgers cannot compare to Gerrard when it comes to legendary status. His contribution over more than fifteen years has been absolutely extraordinary, unquantifable in its value. Without Gerrard’s input, Liverpool would be about as close to winning the league, or any other trophy for that matter, as Tranmere Rovers. To expect him to drive Liverpool forward forever is extremely unrealistic.

As with most things in football, the truth of this matter probably lies somewhere in the middle. Rodgers has a dilemma of how to manage Gerrard at this stage of his career whilst at the same time keeping him happy and the fans off his back. There is also something to be said for the fact that Gerrard, still with much left to offer, needs resting occasionally with big games coming up.

Just as when he made his debut sixteen years ago to the day, Gerrard came off the bench to the acclaim of Anfield. The circumstances on Saturday, however, could hardly have been more different.

Photograph: wikipedia