The British Muslim Poll: Flawed, But Not Worthless
By Dominic Walsh
Once again, much controversy has been generated by the findings of a poll of British Muslims. Earlier this week, ICM conducted a survey on behalf of Channel 4 of 1,081 adult British Muslims. At first glance, their findings appear disturbing. The statistic which generated the most headlines is that 52% of those surveyed believe homosexuality should be illegal in Britain. Others include the 38% who apparently believe ‘Jewish people wield too much power in Britain’, the 47% who would find it morally unacceptable for homosexuals to teach children, and the 39% who think ‘wives should always obey their husbands’.
The last time something like this happened, it was easy for those of a liberal persuasion to dismiss the poll as scaremongering. The Sun’s infamous ‘1 in 5 Brit Muslims sympathy for jihadis’ headline was rightly derided as an attempt to deliberately skew the findings of their own poll. By using vague terms like ‘sympathy’ (one can ‘sympathise’ with British Muslims who have travelled to Syria without agreeing with their actions), they engineered a set of data which allowed them to wrongly imply a large proportion of British Muslims were potential terrorists.
This time it isn’t quite so simple. Oh, there are methodological flaws with the poll, of course. For instance, it only surveyed Muslims in areas where the Muslim proportion of the population is higher than 20%. Given that people’s views are often undeniably shaped by the environment in which they live, might we not naturally expect Muslims surrounded by their co-religionists to be – on average – more socially conservative than those in so-called ‘integrated’ areas?
But over 50% of British Muslims live in such areas. Even if every Muslim living in the areas not surveyed thinks homosexuality should not be illegal, the overall figure would still stand at 26% who think it should be. If we extrapolate this upwards from the 1,081 who were surveyed to the 2.7 million Muslims who live in Britain, that is still 700,000 people. That is still worryingly high.
The former equality commissioner Trevor Philips has been criticised for his response to the poll. In fairness, some of the language he used was unnecessarily alarmist – the claim that there was a ‘chasm’ between Muslim opinion and the rest of the country, for instance. 50% is not 100%, after all, and a closer look at the data reveals that respondents were given the option to ‘slightly agree’, ‘mainly agree’, or ‘strongly agree’ with certain positions. A nuanced set of data requires a nuanced response, not one which implicitly encourages an ‘us and them’ mentality. This is something we as Durham students need to be particularly wary of – this newspaper reported in February that Muslim students ‘feel isolated’ at Durham due to certain misconceptions.
There were many positive findings from the ICM survey, which have largely been ignored by the media – only 4% said they sympathised with the actions of terrorists, for example, and 88% said Britain was a good place to live overall. A crucial lesson from the survey is that ‘Muslims’ do not have some sort of ‘hive mind’, as is arguably implied by misleading questions like ‘What do British Muslims really think?’. There is huge diversity of opinion within this religion, as there is in any other.
Nevertheless, the findings are too concerning to ignore, and some have. With depressing predictability, The Guardian and The Independent both produced opinion pieces dismissing the findings as ‘dangerous and wrong’, and calling Channel 4 ‘irresponsible’ for releasing them. They cited minor methodological flaws which, as discussed, did not actually render the data invalid. They engaged in puerile whataboutery such as ‘there are real concerns within faith communities in general’. They claimed this was a ‘single uncorroborated poll’, which is patently untrue.
Liberal Muslim and counter-extremist Maajid Nawaz rightly pointed out that poll after poll from different sources has shown ‘statistically significant levels of illiberal opinion’ in Islamic communities. He also made the excellent point that any errors in such polls should be rectified with more data that shows different results, not defensive posturing.
The notion that certain facts are too ‘dangerous’ to release to the public is certainly a worrying one. But more worrying is the fact that by taking such a stance, liberals abandon some of the most vulnerable groups in this country, who might welcome the opening up of the debate. Liberal Muslims. Muslim feminists. LGBT Muslims. Ex-Muslim atheists. Ahmadi Muslims. Minorities within minorities, who stand to suffer the most from regressive social attitudes held, not by all or even most members of their communities, but by a minority significant enough to make their lives very difficult.
If anything, polls like these disprove the notion that we only need to worry about the ‘minuscule minority’ who join groups like ISIS. Extremism encompasses far more than just terrorism, and what is the re-criminalisation of homosexuality if it is not an extreme position? The findings of such polls should not be allowed to give ammunition to anti-Muslim scaremongering and generalisations, but if we truly believe in the liberal principles of British society, they should give us some cause for concern and further debate.
Photograph by Almas Baig via Flickr
