Unwanted blast from the past overshadows Villa’s cup heroics
By Will Fremont-Barnes

There were times at Villa Park on Saturday when it felt less like being at a football match and more like getting caught up in a riot. As coins, stones, spit and ripped up seats rained down from the upper tier of the North Stand, hurtling at a dangerously fast speed towards a number of home fans where we were standing, it suddenly mattered little that Aston Villa had just scored their second goal to seal a semi-final spot in the FA Cup.
Given the behaviour of a worryingly large number, there was little to celebrate. When Scott Sinclair scored a brilliant second goal, cutting onto his right foot before curling a shot into the furthest corner of the net at the Holte End, a new wave of hostility was unleashed. A section of home fans began goading the visitors in the tier above them and in the stand to the side of them. Then came the extraordinary backlash of objects being thrown into our stand, which contained a number of children and older people as well as the mindless yobs who had spent the game exchanging obscenities with away fans rather than focusing their attention on the field.
Those missile throwing Albion fans let themselves and their club down, particularly endangering others in the ground with the seats they threw, most of which were aimed at spectators below them rather than at the pitch. The many Villa fans who invaded the pitch with a few minutes still remaining also tarnished what should have been a great afternoon. At full-time there was hardly any grass visible, such was the extent of the second pitch invasion. Players of both sides were rushed to safety in the tunnel, with Fabian Delph complaining about being bitten and Callum McManaman getting involved in an angry confrontation with supporters.
The atmosphere outside the ground was tense, always threatening to boil over. A number of scuffles broke out after the game as thousands of fans descended on Witton, the nearest train station, as a considerable number of police dressed in riot gear attempted to maintain order, their dogs barking menacingly as the tension grew. A few glass bottles were launched in both directions, though none seemed to hit their target. Several vehicles found themselves caught in the crossfire, grinding to a halt as fans surrounded them, some banging on the doors and windows.
Minor injuries aside, it is something of a miracle that nobody was seriously hurt. Tim Sherwood, whose passion and enthusiasm is infectious, certainly cannot be accused of whipping up the fervour that led to Saturday’s nastiness, but it was wrong of him to dedicate the victory to the fans on a night that so many of them had brought the club into disrepute. It was clear when the first pitch invasion happened that the referee should have brought the game to an end. West Bromwich Albion were never likely to score twice in the remaining few minutes given their lack of opportunities for the previous hour and a half, and it would have been wise for Anthony Taylor to have ended the game, or at least brought the players off temporarily, rather than allowing tensions to boil over further.
It would be wrong to assume that the standard of behaviour at games is slipping on the basis of this one game. There were mitigating factors that go some way to explaining the disorder. The late kick-off time for a local derby was surprising, and it was clear on the way to the game that many fans had already spent much of the day drinking before the half past five start. Equally surprising was the discovery when entering the lower tier of the North Stand that half of the 6500 away contingent was situated above us. A few items were thrown well before Villa took the lead in the 51st minute through Delph and the barrage began. It is also often the case that those intent on causing trouble crawl out from the woodwork for cup games.
Those caveats aside, there is a concern that the general standard of conduct at football is beginning to deteriorate. Focusing on the racist chanting of Chelsea fans on the Paris Metro last month in some way detracted from the fact that their collective behaviour in the French capital was, for the second season running, indefensibly yobbish. Saturday’s disturbance came just the weekend after trouble at Rotherham’s game with Millwall in the Championship. You only have to spend a Saturday evening heading back to Durham on the train to encounter unpleasant behaviour from people heading back from an afternoon at the football.
After decades of football being tarnished by antisocial behaviour, it seemed as though we had moved away from a culture of violence and vandalism. Events at Villa Park were a stark reminder that football still has some way to progress.
Photograph: Will Fremont-Barnes
