Review: 100 Days of Hope and Fear

By David Knowles

David Knowles reviews David Torrance’s recent book that focuses on the Scottish independence referendum 

Photograph: Luath Press
Photograph: Luath Press

First up in this trio of referendum reviews is the historian and biographer David Torrance. His work 100 Days of Hope and Fear is an engaging diary and traces Torrance’s experiences over the final hundred days of the referendum campaign. Witty, perceptive and honest the book is a very useful ‘way in’ to understanding the referendum. Torrance makes a number of sharp observations on both campaigns and his book is incredibly valuable to get a personal sense of how both sides came across on the ground.

Furthermore it is refreshing to read a work from an author who strove to maintain their ‘professional neutrality’ during the campaign. By refusing to ally himself to either ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ Torrance rises above many of his colleagues who, during the last 100 days of the campaign, resigned themselves to partisan advocacy. His criticism (of both sides) is all the sharper and insightful for this refusal to ‘pick a side.’

Torrance’s prose is terse but effective, narrating great moments of the campaign simply but managing to accurately convey their significance.

‘…we wandered over to the Usher Hall for ‘A Night for Scotland,’ a very National Collective evening of song, poetry and general hip-ness. There was, it has to be said, an extraordinary atmosphere, with lots of trendy young Yessers getting high on the excitement of it all.’

He sense correctly how intense political feeling can blur the boundary with religious faith.  For example, Torrance relates witnessing conversion narratives aimed at him.

‘On our way to the restaurant  we passed the Newington Yes ‘shop’ and an old guy accosted me to evangelise about how he used to be a trade unionist, Labour Party member etc and now he was voting Yes. I asked him if he believed independence would deliver socialism and he practically exploded: ‘Yes! It’s got to! Scotland’s a socialist country!’

The vocabulary that Torrance uses here is particularly fascinating – the man he encounters does not ‘talk’ to him normally, or even ‘argue,’ ‘dispute’ or ‘attempt to persuade.’ No, the emotion is such that ‘evangelise’ is the best way Torrance can think to describe his behaviour.

Torrance also refuses, unlike many other authors, to over eulogise the referendum,

‘For some reason I expected to be seized by the enormity of it all, but in fact it just felt like every other occasion I’ve voted at the same polling station.’

And later on, after the vote,

‘I was struck by how normal everything was: most folk I saw in Glasgow and Edinburgh were just getting on with their lives, as of course they should.

It is a pity that Torrance refrains from getting too involved in the debates that dominated the final stretch of the campaign, too often he hints at arguments and disputes but refuses to delve deeper and give more complex analysis. By his own admission this is because the book is supposed to be a dramatic, personal account of the campaign, not a technical and political one. However readers unfamiliar with the ins and outs of the referendum campaign will bemoan the lack of context and explanation for the arguments within which Torrance finds himself embroiled.

For thrilling political drama told by a likeable and intelligent narrator, look no further than the exhilarating 100 Days of Hope and Fear. 

David Knowles is studying for a Masters and contributes to ‘Scotland Decides’ for STV. He tweets @djknowles22