Comment debates: Why do we wear makeup?

Why do we wear makeup? Is it a feminist issue? Comment examines both sides of the debate.

Tilda Williams

You can wear it to attract others – and it’s okay to admit that

Since the ancient Egyptians women have been lining their eyes, coloring their lips, and altering their complexion. Not all women wear makeup, trends are always changing, and sometimes history gets in the way, but it seems fair to say that generations of women have inherited makeup as an essential part of femininity.

Today, our social media is saturated with heavily made-up women, tutorials, and advertisements, and we are accustomed to the idea of makeup as a fundamental part of a woman’s life. Turn on the TV and you will not see a single female face, from prime-time drama to trashy reality shows, who isn’t wearing some amount of makeup.  

To suggest then that wearing make-up so you are attractive to others is pandering to the male gaze is ludicrous and insulting.

Because wearing make-up is something traditionally only done by women, it is often perceived as frivolous, and the amount of time and money women spend on make-up is mocked as excessive, fueled by insecurities or manipulative marketing, completely regardless of the amount of skill it demands.

Yet a lot of men continue to admire women who work in makeup (partly because even the most basic layer of foundation really can work wonders), to date women who wear makeup, and to be attracted and impressed by those with elegantly made-up faces. The parody headline may well read, ‘Man says women don’t need cosmetics to be attractive whilst dating a woman in a full face of makeup.’

A face of makeup isn’t the only reason why someone would be attracted to you; no woman would want her makeup to be her only redeeming feature. But it seems fair to say that a lot of women put on makeup hoping it will make them look good to others; to their partners, or potential partners, male or female; or to friends; or just so they can pull on a night out. It is a nice feeling for anyone of any gender to be attractive to others, to have others admire you.

A woman should only wear makeup to feel good about herself, not to please men, and if men are not pleased by a woman who is bare-faced, that is her fault too, for creating a society where makeup is standard.

To suggest then that wearing makeup so you are attractive to others is pandering to the male gaze is ludicrous and insulting. It suggests that a woman has no right to be sexually liberated, to wear revealing clothes or high-heeled shoes or glitter eyeshadow, to be hungry for sex or love or romance.

Why is it wrong for a woman to want to decorate her face so she can, in her own head or in somebody else’s, be seen as attractive and desirable? The idea that a woman should feel guilty about that is extremely damaging. It suggests that despite the prevalence of makeup in our culture and our media, despite how it is taught to girls from a very young age, you, the woman, are at fault for trying to attract men with it. A woman should only wear makeup to feel good about herself, not to please men, and if men are not pleased by a woman who is bare-faced, that is her fault too, for creating a society where make-up is standard.

Sometimes you want to put glitter on and look good; sometimes it’s nice to feel desired – and nobody has the right to judge you for that.

To criticize why a woman wears makeup is to criticize the natural habits of women, to criticize them for wishing to be attractive to another person. It is a frustrating myth that a woman today should do everything for herself, and that she is responsible for everything that happens to her. Why can’t a woman’s self-worth rely on if she pulls in a nightclub or gets a date, why can’t she wear exactly what she likes and behave as she wishes? Sometimes you want to put glitter on and look good; sometimes it’s nice to feel desired – and nobody has the right to judge you for that.

 

Thea Nikolova

Makeup is for me – and me alone

Debate consistently exists around women’s use of makeup, and the ways in which the beauty industry profits from our insecurities. There are many sides to the conflict; some women argue that wearing makeup is itself an act of feminist empowerment, while others counter this with the belief that in buying into the narrative, women are merely financing a global industry of prescribed beauty standards.

Putting on a fresh face of makeup in the morning gets me ready and excited for the day.

But who do women wear makeup for?

I am of the firm opinion that while there’s nothing wrong with wearing makeup to attract romantic or sexual attention, it simply comes down to this: most women wear it for themselves and themselves only.

I certainly do. Putting on a fresh face of makeup in the morning gets me ready and excited for the day. Sometimes, the only thing that motivates me to leave the comforts of my bed and brave the grey day ahead is the precious 10 minutes I spend with my sparkly powders and colourful lippies.

It might be childish to say but it’s true; I like pretty things. I like to have them, and I like to put them on my face. I like to enter the outside world feeling like my best possible self, and my best self has glittery gold eyelids and dark pink lips, and enough highlight on her cheeks to blind oncoming traffic. I definitely make no attempts to look natural. And I certainly don’t care whether or not some guy I pass likes what he’s seeing.

That’s not to say I don’t care about men’s opinions. It’s just that when it comes to my appearance, I … don’t care about men’s opinions.

That’s not to say I don’t care about men’s opinions. It’s just that when it comes to my appearance, I … don’t care about men’s opinions.

The sad truth is that for a long time, like many other women, I bought into what the industry was selling me; the fear that without their sparkly powders and strange concoctions I was ugly and undesirable. I don’t feel that way anymore, and no one, regardless of gender, should. But a part of me will always feel better with makeup on than without.

It’s about being able to devote those additional fifteen minutes to myself, to saying “you deserve this. This is luxurious, and it’s decadent, and it’s for you.” It’s about seeing the red imprint of my lipstick on a cup, and feeling, weirdly, that deep primal impulse of marking my territory. It’s about greeting my friends with enthusiastic cheek kisses and seeing them carry my lipstick mark with them (NB: never attempt this with another person donning a full face of makeup. They will not appreciate the affection.)

The only important thing is this: feel beautiful in your skin, and enjoy yourself.

At the end of the day, makeup, like many other things, is a part of our daily lives. Whilst not a necessity, it has become almost unavoidable, and like many aspects of life it has its upsides and downsides.

The only important thing is this: feel beautiful in your skin, and enjoy yourself. And if part of feeling beautiful or having a good time comes with painting yourself all the colours of the rainbow – go wild!

Featured Illustration by Navya Labo (Illustrations Editor)

Image by Andrei! via Flickr