On Refugees

Tilda Williams

Nicole Garcia Aguilar is a twenty-four-year-old Honduran woman. She is also, in the eyes of the law, an ‘illegal alien’, a refugee, an asylum-seeker, an immigrant.

Aguilar fled her country after her transgender status led to her being assaulted, receiving death-threats, and having an attempt made on her life. Her legal claim for asylum was granted by a judge. However, immigration authorities still refused to release her. Aguilar appealed, and in the meantime was transferred to a men’s facility where she was often placed in solitary confinement which led to the rapid deterioration of her mental health.

Eventually lawyers obtained her release. Yet she was given none of the essential release paperwork, and when she went to collect it was taken back into custody and transferred to a holding center with known issues of abuse and human rights violations.

If you hadn’t guessed, this story takes place in the United States. It is Kafka-esque and twisted. The legal rulings of judges and the tireless attempts of human rights lawyers are continually undermined by bureaucracy and government institutions who play and rule the system. They control vital paperwork, shunt detainees from centre to centre, and their main purpose is protecting those largely invisible legal boundaries that divide one patch of earth from another under the guise of ‘nation’ and ‘border’, motivated by the belief that it is better that a person dies then be accepted into their country.

It is ironic that these people, so patriotic and intent on protecting the soil of their ‘home-country’ could believe that another person from another patch of land would willingly leave their own home for the unknown without having some true fear driving them. A refugee is, by definition, ‘forced’ to leave their country. The 1951 United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees defines them as being driven by fear of persecution.

We hide behind our boarders to avoid saving lives; we use them as excuses to send people back to situations where they will suffer and die.

In the UK, only around 30% of asylum seekers are granted asylum. Women are often required to provide details of intensely traumatic violence that any person would recognise as requiring years of therapy and specialist invention. Those recognised as refugees are often allowed to spend just five years in the country, regardless of any benefit they bring, though in fact there are over 1,000 medically qualified refugees in Britain. They are likely to be detained awaiting outcomes, live in poverty, and be assaulted.

In the face of such basic facts it seems continually alarming how much we have come to rely on this legal construction of the ‘border’. Territorial arrangements of land, language, and culture are a basic fact of civilisation. Yet our borders today are monstrous weapons of systematic destruction. We hide behind our borders to avoid saving lives; we use them as excuses to send people back to situations where they will suffer and die. We fill the world with pieces of paper to control who can come in and out, and to privilege certain countries with certain administrative capabilities above others. We introduce quotas and examinations to restrict, but always behind the ‘neutral’ voice of the law.

People come to this country because they have nowhere else to go; because they would die to stay in their home, in their house with their family and friends and their job, and everything they loved – and we use legal jargon and abstract restrictions to avoid acknowledging this and to send them away. Our attitude toward borders is prejudiced and colonial, so that with certain countries we are happy to assume a system of relaxed and friendly border control and visa programs, while other countries are treated with suspicion and disdain. An example of this may be the rush to cancel trips and programs to Sri Lanka in the wake of the horrific bombings there, as if the country is a poisonous toad; would you consider cancelling holidays to America in the wake of their frequent terrorist attacks? Or Paris? You can argue that they are our ‘neighbors’ and that we have a historic association with them and that is why we have a closer bond, but this ignores the impact of the colonial legacy that the British Empire left in its wake. Our refusal to behave fairly toward people who live in countries we once cannibalized is sickening.

We must stop hiding behind obscurest language and face the truth: there may be kind people among us, but we are not a kind country anymore.

We need to change the language we use. We hide behind the word ‘refugee’ to avoid acknowledging that these are people are as intelligent, talented and varied as us, their only difference being geography. We avoid accepting that nobody voluntarily leaves their home and country to live in a disease-ridden camp or undertake a perilous ocean crossing. We use the words ‘illegal alien’ to distance ourselves from what is just a person on the wrong side of a border. It is this legal jargon of the law that we use to divide ourselves and escalate the arbitrary differences in how two separate territories govern each other into powerful weapons we can use to punish, to torture, to destroy lives.

The map is not the territory. It is a perverted belief that it is only the strength of its borders that underscores the solidity of a country. It is the people within it that define what their country is. We must stop hiding behind obscurest language and face the truth: there may be kind people among us, but we are not a kind country anymore. We offer aid to people in the detached, impersonal hope that it will keep them from our doors. We are more concerned with bizarre, abstract notions of what it means to be ‘British’ than we are with demonstrating the quality of ourselves, by showing through our actions, our aid, and our open doors, that we do not just say it but truly believe in universal human equality and the right of any person to be safe and happy. Modern borders are just imperialism continued, and until we face that those of us inside them are no better than those outside, we will remain a failed people, and a failed country.

Featured photograph by Garry Knight via Flikr. In text photograph: William Proby via Flikr.