Fleabag: less relatable than Love Island
By Tilda Williams
“The most electrifying, devastating television in years”, “a near-perfect work of art”, “an absolute masterpiece”. It is fair to say the second season of BBC3’s Fleabag was universally lauded by critics for its humour, its apparent honesty and its depiction of apparently realistic millennial life in all its mess and catastrophe. I’ll admit that Fleabag is a well-made, entertaining show, but am forced to take issue with the hyperbolic lauding of it as some generation-defining masterpiece – because I’m not really sure that it is.
It does not seek to challenge the status-quo of class or diversity and exists in a bubble of comfortable wealth and privilege that rarely comes into contact with actual challenges
Fleabag is easy to love. It is a polished BBC production written by Phoebe Waller-Bridge, a privately-educated upper-class (her grandfathers on both sides were Baronets, with one being a Reverend and MP to boot) London-based, RADA-graduating white woman. It is set exclusively in London and its principal characters are a family of white, upper-class heterosexuals (in the second season I counted two actors of colour).
It does not seek to challenge the status-quo of class or diversity and exists in a bubble of comfortable wealth and privilege that rarely comes into contact with actual challenges, which would of course appeal to those white, well-educated, privileged journalists who make up the majority of mainstream television critics in the UK (it is worth admitting here that I am most certainly a pot calling the kettle white, being myself a privileged white female). Fleabag, which is innately sympathetic and defensive of this demographic, and is of a relatively high standard, is therefore an instant attraction.
She’s not in financial difficulty – she’s just at the poor end of being rich
In Season I, for example, Fleabag’s guinea pig-themed café is in jeopardy as Fleabag struggles to make ends meet, and we are supposed to find her financial struggles either sympathetic or amusing (or both). Yet despite being broke, Fleabag is still able to live alone in London, and find the time out of running her café to attend numerous events, such as a church fete on a day that surely could have provided a good café trade (maybe by season II, Fleabag’s café is doing so well she can hire multiple staff and pay them a London living wage). Unlike most young people living in London in cramped shared-accommodation, working unrewarding jobs far distant from an envisioned career, Fleabag gets what she wants. She gets to run her café, she gets to live alone, she gets the loan from the bank to stay afloat. She’s not in financial difficulties – she’s just at the poor end of being rich.
Waller-Bridger grew up in affluent Ealing in West London, and Fleabag never really bothers to go beyond leafy streets of large semi-detached houses. Fleabag’s family, the central cast of the show, all live conveniently close, a situation far removed from the many people in the UK today who don’t have the luxury of living near their parents or siblings, by choice or necessity being forced to other towns or cities for university or jobs, and having to construct their own fragile replacements for family structures.
I could be persuaded to suspend my disbelief in Fleabag’s situation – the realities of life aren’t very interesting I’ll admit – if people didn’t keep insisting on how relatable the show is. Far more relatable, in my opinion, is that much-trashed ITV reality show Love Island. Its cast, though largely white, is often working or middle-class, and from varied regions of the UK. Love Island certainly isn’t an honest show, but it is raw in its depiction of young adults: confused, vulnerable, determined and strong yet fragile, surprisingly easy to hurt, caught up between love and lust and friendship. Georgia Steel insisting on her loyalty or Danni Dyer being tormented by the thought her boyfriend could be cheating on her is a much more real evocation to me of the people surrounding me and how we live than Fleabag’s long-suffering, self-pitying exploits.
I could be persuaded to suspend my disbelief in Fleabag’s situation – the realities of life aren’t very interesting I’ll admit – if people didn’t keep insisting on how relatable the show is
Fleabag may be as selfish, lonely and distraught as any of the Love Island contestants, as prone to making bad decisions as they are. But while Fleabag can have raucous dramatized sex on camera and be lauded for it, when Zara Holland had far less revealing, if real, sex on camera, she was stripped of her Miss GB title and torn apart by the media.
Not only that, but the Love Island contestants are often very candid about their difficulties, their confusions, even their selfishness. Nobody on Love Island is trying to tell you how to live your life. The finale of Fleabag season II, on the other hand involves literal preaching, as the Priest, a white male-authority figure, stands up to tell us how “love is awful…Being a romantic takes a hell of a lot of hope.”
I can’t disagree with what the Priest says, but it is somewhat galling to have this so sincerely preached at me by a man, as if young woman today are not painfully aware of the realities of love and have to be told by a male-authority figure – a figure actively engaged in toying with their emotions despite clearly being in a relationship, as if a guy who is ghosting you sends an out-of-the blue text explaining that the reason he’s been ignoring you is because love is difficult.
Nobody on Love Island is trying to tell you how to live your life
What the Priest says is not revelatory, anymore than the interchangeable cameos of privileged white actresses Fiona Shaw (as the world’s most unrealistic therapist) telling us, “do you want to fuck the priest or do you want to fuck God?” or Kristen Scott-Thomas explaining how “being a woman is pain.” These insights are simplistic and superficial; no real effort is made to engage with ideas of religion, or menopause, or pregnancy, or race, or sexuality, or friendship outside of family. Fleabag appears to interrogate these topics but in fact skims over them in a self-important, self-conscious way, like Waitrose producing a bland own-brand version of an authentic ethnic dish.
For all her fourth-wall breaking, Fleabag – and Phoebe Waller-Bridger – isn’t actually interested in us. She’s only interested in herself
Love Island reflects the unpleasant, difficult realities of my life back at me – and, make no mistake, I welcome the portrayal of difficult, complicated modern women on our screens. But Fleabag exploits such realities to shock and amuse a privileged middle-aged audience, turning true angst into moralising sympathy-porn. We are offered no new insights; we just feel sorry for Fleabag. The show won’t stand the test of time, because ultimately the idea of Fleabag is much more rewarding than its realities. For all her fourth-wall breaking, Fleabag – and Phoebe Waller-Bridger – isn’t actually interested in us. She’s only interested in herself.
Image by Isabelle Adam via Flickr.
