Celebrity casting in theatre should be encouraged

Cumberbatch Hamlet (Polly Stefanova)

By Florianne Humphrey

When I was surprised with tickets to the new, highly acclaimed Hamlet production, my first thought admittedly was: “I’m going to be in the same room as Benedict Cumberbatch.” Should I be ashamed of that? No.

Although I didn’t join the hordes of eager fans at the stage door hoping to catch a sign of their idol, I am happy to admit, even as an English student, that I wasn’t just going to the play to appreciate the artistry of Hamlet’s famous soliloquy. That doesn’t mean I was there just to appreciate the artistry of Cumberbatch’s face. Cumberbatch is an astounding actor in his own right, and his acting credentials are lengthy enough to merit their own article.

It’s true that there’s been a recent phenomenon in celebrity actors taking on theatrical roles, such as Matt Smith’s musical debut in American Psycho or Rupert Grint’s appearance in Mojo. However, does a celebrity actor’s presence in a production lessen its theatrical value?

Firstly, there needs to be a definition between ‘celebrity’ and ‘celebrity actor’. In the same way that it’s unjust that Zoella’s literary success rides on her vlogging fame, casting X Factor contestant Amelia Lily in American Idol seems to be another marketing ploy, as there must be plenty of trained actors suitable for the role. However, in the case of Cumberbatch, he is an actor in his own right.  He’s not a celebrity who’s decided to dip into another craft because they feel their name will sell a product (why do so many Disney Channel stars discover they’re born to be singers?).

Cumberbatch is famous because he’s good at what he does, and so deserves a role as one of the most well-known tragic characters in theatrical history. Saying Cumberbatch shouldn’t have the part because of his celebrity status suggests that once actors hit Hollywood, they must be banned from developing their craft in case they deprive others of fame. Acting is a competitive industry – if the best happen to be famous, then so be it.

True, there are probably many other lesser-known actors who could have played the role just as well as Cumberbatch, and I’m not naively ignoring the fact that it’s not just his talent but also his name that sold tickets. However, just as casting in television and film mixes known faces with unknown ones, theatre should also embrace this approach. And whilst Cumberbatch was the selling point, the popularity of the play meant the other fantastic actors got the opportunity to showcase their talents on a platform that’s gained so much media attention.

The RSC also didn’t rely solely on Cumberbatch for the success of the play. The other, lesser-known actors in Hamlet were also incredible, especially Sian Brooke who played Ophelia with convincing insanity. The scenery was breathtaking, a refreshing change to modernist theatre’s stripped-down set. Nothing could better reflect royal decadence than a huge, life-sized ballroom cut through with a sweeping staircase, lavishly decorated with chandeliers dripping with crystals, stuffed birds, and gold-framed oil paintings. There was also a great eye for detail, from the ingenious use of slow motion acting to focus attention on Hamlet during dramatic monologues to the post-interval change from an extravagant to an apocalyptic set that mirrored the tragic demise of the characters.

Celebrity actors in theatre shouldn’t be something we turn our noses up at. In the same way that Usain Bolt is famous because he’s the best 100m runner, and therefore people will pay more for him, so is it justified that fans of Cumberbatch will queue for hours to see his performance of Hamlet because his fame ensures a quality performance.

Even if Cumberbatch’s teenage fans bought the tickets purely for his sake, if they leave the theatre enchanted by Shakespeare’s spell, then that’s an even bigger success than ticket sales. If Benedict Cumberbatch is one of the ways to make Shakespeare more accessible and appealing to the younger generation, then celebrity presence in the theatre should be encouraged.

Finally, for me, the thrill of seeing an actor I admire performing in one of the greatest plays ever written made it an undeniably memorable evening – and surely that’s what theatre is all about.

Illustration: Polly Stefanova