Amy Schumer: not the only funny female comic

ASchumer (Polly Stefanova)

By Sofya Grebenkina

Amy Schumer has made a slow but steady rise on the comedy circuit. First performing stand-up in restaurants as sideline entertainment, she has now written and starred in her very own film Trainwreck. However, Schumer isn’t the sole, successful female in a comedy world dominated by men. Instead, her success actually heralds a more significant change in how we are beginning to appreciate more and more female talent in the comedy industry.

Despite several easily disprovable studies, women are not naturally devoid of the ability to be funny. Before Amy Schumer came along and grasped the media’s attention there were still female comics who were raking in crowds at their solo shows. To name only a select few, there were the likes of Joan Rivers and her ‘protégé’ Margaret Cho, dishing out their trademark brand of controversial humour. Rivers was more than just a comic, and her one-liners like, “If God wanted us to bend over he’d put diamonds on the floor,” inspired women around her to keep holding the comedic banner after she passed away.

Despite several easily disprovable studies, women are not naturally devoid of the ability to be funny.

It is this same type of crude, uncensored humour for which Amy Schumer is now famous. On The Ellen Show, to a daytime audience, she appears in a toned down and demure guise as she talks about Dianna Agron and going to the cinema. Yet on Jimmy Fallon’s or Conan’s talk shows she talks more explicitly about her puberty or her ‘harassment’ of male celebrities at events.

It is in her stand-up shows where Schumer appears most genuine, as she does not shy away from having a laugh at topics that were previously considered to be private concerns. Her show Mostly Sex Stuff is exactly that, and is a one-hour, hilarity-filled journey through her flings and dating escapades. Inside Amy Schumer, her 2013 TV venture on Comedy Central, boasts such titles for sketches as ‘Dog Stripper’ or ‘Herpes Scare’ which don’t disappoint in their content either.

Schumer’s ability to trespass on conversational taboos may be what has allowed her to succeed, but it is also what has held other women in comedy back. Schumer often recycles her content for her shows, sometimes verbatim, yet currently she is considered to be a rising star. It is therefore perhaps not that she has unprecedented stores of originality or talent, but that she is allowed to mine a wider range of material than women before her were able to do.

Misogyny takes many forms, but is at its most dangerous when it is underhand – unrecognizable at first glance. Audiences have excused male comics for being brash because it was part of some mistaken idea of masculinity. Meanwhile, female comics have had to set their own standards on what can and cannot be said by a woman. Tina Fey in her autobiography Bossypants tells the following anecdote about Amy Poehler’s beginnings on Saturday Night Live:

“Amy was in the middle of some such nonsense with Seth Meyers across the table, and she did something vulgar as a joke. I can’t remember what it was exactly, except it was dirty and loud and ‘unladylike’.

“Jimmy Fallon, who was arguably the star of the show at the time, turned to her and in a faux-squeamish voice said, ‘Stop that! It’s not cute! I don’t like it.’

“Amy dropped what she was doing, went black in the eyes for a second, and wheeled around on him. ‘I don’t fucking care if you like it.’ Jimmy was visibly startled. Amy went right back to enjoying her ridiculous bit.”

Incidentally, both Tina Fey and Amy Poehler are also starring in their first film Sisters, a comedy about two siblings letting go of their childhood home. Their humour, although initially frowned upon even by fellow comics, has eventually led them to play major roles in TV programmes, award shows, and now their own film.

Jimmy Fallon’s response to their ‘unladylike’ comedy – a response which is perhaps still rallied at them by others – is probably not because it is crude. Comedians like Tina Fey, Amy Poehler, and now Amy Schumer, have been very open about and focused on what it means to be female. Male comics are well and able to find humour in topics such as gender roles and the perception of the female body. However, female comics are able to approach these topics from a place of genuine understanding. That’s not to say that women don’t ridicule their flaws but that it sounds more genuine. And in this case I believe that Freud’s theory actually works; jokes can only originate from a place of truth.

The rise of the female comic is not limited to the Amy Schumer phenomenon. She is not the only talented female comic out there, and certainly not the only exception to the notion that ‘women aren’t funny’. Instead, she is part of a much longer tradition of women being able to have their voices heard increasingly more publicly, and one that is applicable to much more than their increasing prevalence and success in comedy.

Illustration: Polly Stefanova