Australopithecus deyiremeda, another hominin or a grab for fame?

7283201084_ea089059a0_c

By Luke Andrews

Announced to consternation on May 28th in the journal Nature, paleoanthropologist Yohannes Haile-Selassie attempted to add a new branch to the human family tree. He proposes a new species of Australopithecine, by the name of deyiremeda. The word, borrowed from the Afar language of Djibouti, Eritrea and Ethiopia, means ‘close’. This is perhaps fitting, considering the potential for it to be subsumed into an established species.

The proposal draws its foundations from findings of an upper and lower jaw, and a foot in 2009. The first jaw was discovered exposed on the surface in Burtele, Ethiopia, and radiometrically dated to 3.5–3.3 million years ago. These dates overlap with the known time frame of A. afarensis, dated at 3.9–2.8 million years. Is it possible that two hominin species occupied the same area?

“The question now is not whether it is a hominin, but if it is a new species of hominin,” commented Durham lecturer Dr Andy Shuttleworth.

“The question now is not whether it is a hominin, but if it is a new species of hominin.”

Dr Haile-Selassie, discoverer of the proposed species, highlights its morphological differences as a foundation for splitting it from the afarensis lineage. It could have emerged via cladogenesis from A. afarensis or diverged from Ardipithecus.

There are two other proposed hominin species that would also have been wandering Africa during this period: Australopithecus bahrelghazali in Chad and Kenyanthropus Platyops in Kenya. They suggest the possibility that there was more than one hominin in Africa during this period, providing greater support for the presence of A. deyiremeda.

“This new species is yet another confirmation that A. afarensis was not the only potential human ancestor species that roamed in what is now the Afar region,” stated Dr Haile-Selassie.

A. deyiremeda’s teeth have a thicker layer of enamel and its jaw is more robust than of A. afarensis. New species have been proposed on less before. Homo heidelbergensis, for instance, is a complete mishmash of morphological features, interwoven into a single species concept despite a noticeable absence of apomorphies (derived traits or “innovations”).

Are these morphological differences indicative of a new species or a reflection of plasticity? Biomechanical studies have shown a dichotomy in bone structure depending on activity patterns. Swimmers tend to develop lighter bones, whilst runners will develop denser ones. Could a difference in activity patterns in a population of A. afarensis have caused the morphological variation that is currently being used to postulate a new species?

“[The morphological] distinctions are very very subtle,” claims paleoanthropologist Bill Kimbel of the Institute of Human Origins, suggesting that taking a step-back from these fossils may be more profitable.  The fossils may just be an example of morphological plasticity, as opposed to an actual new species.

To tear these fossils away from A. afarensis, consideration of the environment is paramount. As it is unlikely that two separate species could occupy the same environmental niche, especially for the 200,000 year period proposed, the need to establish their habitats is of the utmost importance. The ‘competitive exclusion principle’, in its most embryonic form, is the idea that eventually one species will outcompete another if they both occupy the same niche. Sadly, this strand of argument continues to lack data.

“[We can’t] say anything about the nature of interaction or ecological differences between A. afarensis and A. deyiremeda” argues Steph Melillo of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology. Without further fossil and environmental evidence, it remains premature to call this a new species.

Dr Andy Shuttleworth is himself undecided: “I’m currently jumping between these two interpretations, though favouring [morphological plasticity] at the moment.” However Dr Haile-Selassie, as would be expected, continues to hold fast to the idea of a new species: “Some of our colleagues are going to be sceptical about this new species, which is not unusual.”

It is imperative that further fossils of this species are unearthed before anything concrete can be said about its existence and its ecological niche. For now, A. deyiremeda should be left on the sidelines of human evolution as an untenable species without further data. Its fossils should be attributed to A. afarensis, not postulated as an individual species. The evidence at present suggests that it is no more than geographical morphological variation within a population.

Photograph: Tim Evanson on Flickr