Better gift giving – with Science
By Luke Andrews
With the Black Friday sales behind us, the pressure is now on to find that perfect gift for your friends and family. Students all across Durham are scratching their heads and wondering ‘what should I get my loved ones for Christmas?’
The anxiety often felt when it comes to gift giving is normal, as presents may seem like a representation of the strength of a relationship or proof of knowing someone well. Questions abound. What would they really want – or need? How much should I spend? Is a chic stylish knickknack better than a purposeful gift?
A recent study published in the Oxford Journal of Consumer Research suggests that the best gifts are the most practical. Students were cornered by an energetic research team and asked to stand ten feet away from each other. One was allocated the role of giver the other the receiver. They were handed a sheet asking them if they would prefer to give their friend a ‘fashionable, aesthetically pleasing stylish pen with special grip’ or a ‘sturdy, long life pen.’ This choice is meant to represent the common trade-off between desirability and practicality of gifted objects – with one simple example.
Perhaps surprisingly, gift receivers preferred the practical essay-ready pen compared to the less useful but considerably nicer adorned one. Gift givers reported choosing “thoughtful and considerate gifts”, which usually meant the most distinctive ones, but these were rejected by the receiver in favour of practicality more often than not.
And better gifts may actually come cheaper than showy ones. A higher price will “not engender more appreciation from the receivers” stated Boskin, a contributor to the journal.
The quality of gift-wrap also came under scrutiny recently in American Scientist. According to Novemsky, a professor of marketing at Yale University, it is better to give presents with minimal wrapping. He argues that better wrapping raises expectations for a gift, increasing the risk of a receiver being disappointed.
“It’s like giving someone a Sears gift card in a Tiffany box”, he says. Sears is a lower-end chain of American Department stores, whilst Tiffany represents the upper-market. He suggests wrapping gifts in brown paper to ensure that expectations are not raised too high.
These studies have revealed that whilst as the giver, you may feel that it is more appropriate to bestow on your loved ones a beautiful flashy item, a much more practical one tends to be preferred. Try to present it in simple (but neat!) wrapping paper. It’s not about how much you spend on a gift, but about the use the receiver will put it to.
Photograph: Alan Cleaver via Flickr
