Durham University ‘miles off’ Carbon Reduction Targets

By Luke Andrews

The University failed to reach its sustainability target in 2014, and is likely to miss it again in 2020. Some efforts have been made to reduce emissions through the installation of low and zero carbon technologies, but this has been inadequate to meet the targets. Durham is currently ranked 67th out of 150 universities and 16th out of the 24 Russell Group universities by the People & Planet sustainable universities index.
For the period 2013-2014, Durham University missed its target by just under 19%. The target was a 30% reduction in CO2 emissions against a 2008/09 baseline. It achieved 11% reduction for Scope 1 and 2, which includes emissions produced directly and indirectly by university activity, and a 5-6% reduction for scope 3 which is mostly not included in the target.
For the period 2014 – 2020, the University aims for a 43% reduction in CO2 emissions against a 2005/06 baseline according to the Carbon Management Plan produced by Durham University Greenspace.
However, when asked about this, the University said “The University’s Carbon Management Plan 2 [is] currently under review.”
They may be considering abandoning this target in light of the Estates Management Plan, which threatens to increase the University’s carbon emissions.
These targets are set by Hefce, the Higher Education Funding Council for England, although there is no legal requirement to adhere to them.
People & Planet ranked Durham University 67th out of 150 UK universities for sustainability. This also put Durham 16th out of 24 Russell Group universities. It was beaten by Oxford(46th), Exeter(16th) and Newcastle University (8th). The top 3 universities in the index were Nottingham Trent University (1st), University of Brighton (2nd) and Manchester Metropolitan University (3rd).
This failure to meet carbon reduction targets is a trend amongst UK Universities.”University commitment to meeting the climate challenge is dwindling” said People & Planet in a press release.
When asked why targets are not being met, Durham University said “this was due to a number of reasons, including an increase in the number of buildings on the University estate.” This is in direct contradiction to the Carbon Management Plan report produced by Greenspace which states “Absolute targets must be met irrespective of any growth in the University estate.”

In answer to why Durham is not meeting its energy targets, an internal report stated;
“This seems slow progress but it must be borne in mind that there is a difference between successfully completing a project and seeing success on the bottom line.”
The University’s shrinking commitment is highlighted further by the failure of the Carbon Management Team, the group responsible for ensuring the University meets its targets, to meet since 2015, according to the University website. The last meeting ended with no time set for the next. When asked about this, the University said “The University’s Carbon Management Team continues to meet regularly”.

“We’re not doing very well”, said Paul Riddlesden, Energy Manager at Durham University, when asked about the University’s progress.
He feels the University’s failure is partly down to a lack of student pressure.

“I am surprised at the lack of student influence” he said with reference to carbon emission reduction plans endorsed by the University.
Some low and zero carbon technologies have been installed onsite, but not enough to meet the carbon reduction targets.
Voltage Power Optimisation Technology was in 5 buildings on the Science Site as of 2010. It works by increasing the efficiency of energy use within a building. In the Arthur Holmes building, it has reduced electricity use by 11.7%, and saved the University ÂŁ21,060 annually.
Combined Heat and Power systems were installed in 8 buildings as of March 2016, including Collingwood and St Aiden’s. The system is a low carbon alternative, using natural gas to fuel electrical generation. In a review carried out by the University, the technology was shown to save ÂŁ56,529 annually, meaning it took under 4 years for the University to save money on the installation. However, as the price of this technology recently rose by 20% these figures are now outdated.

Zero carbon technologies have also been added to the University’s estate. They include photovoltic panels which had been installed on 10 University buildings by March 2016. Zero carbon technologies are now responsible for supplying 3% of the total energy needed by the University.
The University has also begun to take BREEAM certification seriously. This is a world leading sustainability assessment method. It evaluates the procurement, design, construction and operation of a new build against targets that are based on performance benchmarks. The Palatine centre achieved a BREEAM excellent, for its inclusion of sedum roofing, solar thermal modules, solar PV panels, air source heat pumps, solar shading, and rainwater harvesting.
Greenspace was founded to headline all environmental activities. It is responsible for the 10 different green icons that can be seen on campus and sends weekly emails to students to encourage carbon saving behaviour.
These efforts have won Durham various awards. It won the category for continuous improvement; institutional change at the National Green Gown awards, and a silver in the North-East England Tourism awards. For the Green Gown award, the judges commented that they were “impressed by the brand and narrative the University has developed.” There were no facts or figures presented as to how much CO2 these efforts have saved.
In the Carbon Reduction Category of the Green Gown awards, Durham was outflanked by Dundee and Angus College in Scotland. Despite not being a world leading institution, its carbon emissions were reduced by 43% against its initial 2010 footprint.
Although it is great that the University won the silver award for sustainable tourism, it is important to point out that Durham is first and foremost an academic institution, not a hotel.
The University has made a good start with green technology, but there is much still to be done. Investments in low and zero carbon technologies have been made, but not at the scale needed to reach the targets. If Durham wishes to set such high targets, it should pursue them.

Photograph: Luke Andrews