Criticism: a necessary evil?

By Kyriaki Kyriacou

To attend Durham University is to be exposed to a plethora of new experiences, one of which being amateur theatre. Many eagerly seize the opportunity to get involved with a student institution that has nurtured the talents of Ed Gamble, Charlotte Riley, and Roger Moore, to name a few. Durham Student Theatre’s reputation precedes it; productions go on to find success not just on campus, but on a national level with plays regularly being selected for the Edinburgh Fringe Festival. Approximately seventy productions are put on each year but, at the risk of sounding sacrilegious, not all of them are masterpieces. As the calendar becomes inundated with performances of everything from fin-du-siècle drama to experimental (sometimes disturbing) physical pieces, it becomes necessary to separate true talent and flair from mere misguided theatrical ambition – and this is where the reviewer comes in.

It is understandable that some people may be resistant to criticism, especially after a cast and crew have poured so much time and dedication into their own passion project. To then deem a play ‘unspectacular’ or ‘torturous’ is the equivalent of telling a mother who has just spent thirty hours in labour that her child is ugly. You just don’t do it. Art, much like beauty itself, is subjective and what may seem obscene to one person is refreshing to another. Criticism becomes even more controversial in the university setting, as the close-knit circle of the Durham Drama community means that literally everyone knows each other. This results in reviewers who may err on the cautious side in order to satisfy a friend – or those who take the Machiavellian approach, and use reviews to unleash a personal vendetta on someone who has wronged them.

Obviously, credit should be given where it is due and reviews should not be seen as an opportunity for a writer to let out their sadistic impulses just to make a more engaging read. Above all, criticism should be constructive. There is no point tearing a production to pieces if you can’t then point out how it could be put back together again in the future. To those who are anxious about the ability of a review to make-or-break a theatrical career, it must be noted that there is never just one definitive review. The beauty of mass media is that it provides us with endless sources, each offering a wide-array of verdicts. It is important to remember that reviewers are not divine beings imbued with some sort of all-encompassing theatrical knowledge from birth. They are just people who have been asked to give an opinion, and readers can make of that opinion what they will.

That being said, the very nature of drama is that it’s a public spectacle. Sophocles and Euripides didn’t write plays for their own private pleasure, but performed them at Drama festivals such as the Dionysia, where they would be judged and eventually rewarded. The existence of art depends on an interactive and critical audience. If you go in search of praise, you must also accept the possibility of encountering criticism. Yes, to have someone slander your work can be heart-wrenching but it can also be illuminating, showing you where you went wrong and how you can improve. In the words of Churchill:

‘Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body; it calls attention to the development of an unhealthy state of things. If it is heeded in time, danger may be averted; if it is suppressed, a fatal distemper may develop.’

After all, criticism is rarely unfounded. You can either ignore the symptoms of an afflicted production or you can treat them – the reviewer merely diagnoses the problem.

Photograph: TEDx Stuttgart, Flickr