We are better off together
It was hard not to laugh on Monday as the Saltire was feebly lifted above Downing Street. The first poll in over two years of campaigning had shown a lead for the Yes campaign and Westminster had panicked.
Their reaction was comical and will only have convinced more Scottish voters that this coalition is completely and utterly inept. But their ineptitude is not a reason to break up a union that has lasted for over 300 years.
Of course, disillusionment with Westminster is not the only reason why almost half of the Scottish population has decided it will vote for independence this Thursday, but it has played a significant role. As Alex Salmond likes to remind the Scottish public at any given opportunity, “there are more Giant Pandas in Scotland than there are Tory MPs,” and it’s a salient point. For the last four years, we have been governed by a Tory-led government, a party that won only 16.7% of the Scottish vote in the 2010 General Election, the fourth biggest party in Scotland.
In contrast, Gordon Brown’s Labour Party won 42% of the Scottish vote, the highest ever in percentage terms, and yet were left with no power. It seems clear that were the Labour Party in control of Westminster now, this referendum would not be as tight as it looks to be.
The reason for this is that Salmond and the Yes Campaign have been very good at persuading the Scottish people that this referendum is about Scotland vs. the Tories. It is not.
Yes Scotland’s favourite buzzword over the past few months has been ‘scaremongering’: Osbourne ‘scaremongering’ over the currency, the banks ‘scaremongering’ over leaving Scotland, Darling ‘scaremongering’ about oil. But in reality the Yes Campaign are just as culpable of ‘scaremongery’ as Better Together, recently suggesting that unless we gain independence we will be stuck with a Cameron/Farage coalition in the Spring, while all polls suggest that a hung parliament with Labour as the biggest party is the most likely outcome at present.
But this is not a question of party politics, nor even really a question of identity, but rather a question of the kind of country I would like to live in, and the most effective means of achieving this. For many Scots, the socialist model described by Alex Salmond is incredibly attractive, but as Alan Rusbridger argued earlier this week, “nationalism is not an answer to social injustice”. Indeed, the two most prized areas of Scottish society – education and health – could be in serious danger in the event of a ‘yes’ vote.
Unlike students from the rest of the UK, Scottish students are currently offered a free university education in Scotland. If we are to take Alex Salmond’s word that Scotland will gain immediate membership of the EU, then we must also assume that students coming to Scottish universities from the rest of the UK would have to be treated the same as EU students, i.e. they could no longer be charged the £9,000 tuition fees as this would be discriminatory.
With this vast loss of income for Scottish universities it is almost inevitable that Scotland’s free tuition would be scrapped in a matter of years.
It seems clear that education has been a great success in Scotland since it became a devolved power in 1998, and the same can be said of healthcare and the NHS. Unlike the rest of the UK, the Scottish government has resisted any privatisation of the NHS and has scrapped prescription charges too.
The Yes Vote claim that if Scotland votes ‘no’, the NHS would be in jeopardy is a barefaced lie. Scotland already has power-of-policy over the NHS and so the only way any of it could be privatised is if an elected Scottish government in Holyrood chose to do so – which is unlikely to ever happen. However, the Scottish National Party themselves admit in their White Paper that an independent Scotland would have to undergo cuts of around £6bn. This really would have an impact on the issues that matter to the Scottish public. It would not be the socialist utopia, free from all austerity, that many Yes-voters dream of.
Whatever the outcome of the referendum on the 18th September, this campaign will live in the memories of all involved quite possibly for the rest of their lives. It has been a shining example of how a democracy should operate: over 97% of Scots have registered to vote and turnout is expected to be around 85% – an unprecedented level in British political history; for the first time in Britain, 16 and 17 year-olds have been given the vote, entrusted with one of the biggest decisions in Scottish history; and the campaigns and debates have reached every corner of Scotland, unrelenting over what has been an exhausting two years of speculation and discussion.
There are positives that can be taken from either outcome, and either outcome will result in constitutional change to our country. But in family, in life, in economics, and in nation, we are better off together.
Illustration: Patrick Brennan

