The end of an era

Read William Pinkney-Baird’s argument for Yes

Read Sandy Thin’s argument for No

15002322117_dc34f5c197_o

By Jade Azim

“The Scottish devolutionary moment should also be English devolutionary moment.”

This is what think tank IPPR suggested in light of plans to decentralise powers to Scotland, the big ‘Home Rule’ promise that will change the politics of this island forever should Scotland vote no and the political elite keep to their guns.

Of course, the politics of this island, and the map, will change in light of a yes vote too.

What is certain in both scenarios is that this political elite will have to find new guns if they are to beat the bullet of the electorate. The people have spoken. The current consensus of the establishment –and yes, that includes you, Mr Farage- that a neoliberal, free market philosophy that enables austerity in such a shocking and non-distributive manner, is in ruins.

Even if Scotland votes no on September 17th, polls among the young suggest that if there is a referendum in the future, at the current rate, Scotland will break away. Westminster has already seen what happens when you take a large swathe of this island for granted; the YouGov poll last week that saw the yes vote ahead for the first time sent shivers through the hallowed corridors of Parliament and induced all major players to catch the Hogwarts Expre –ahem, the almost-privatised East Coast line to Scotland to battle for the Union.

Suddenly, Scotland was offered a bigger brand of regionalism, and some polls have given favour to No again. But this jolt through the spines of the Consensual Three –you know the ones- has triggered a new debate on decentralisation that must now be considered not just for Scotland, but for all regions of the United Kingdom, including a North East that almost a decade ago voted against a North East Assembly.

New devolution, federalism even, will have a huge knock on effect to the standing order, and to the electoral demographics of the country. “From Whitehall to Townhall” is the initiative being considered in large English cities, cities that are generally more liberal than their rural counterparts, to give local metropolitan authorities powers over council tax and even, partially, income tax.

This is not just about practical political power, either. There is a real identity crisis and division in the UK. 62% of Scots do not identify as British, with similar levels of this ostracised sense of identity in Wales and Northern Ireland. These divisions may be historically entrenched, but have undoubtedly been further exacerbated since Thatcher’s ascent to power.

A chasm of socio-political and economic difference eroded away any solidarity previously felt with the wealthier South East of England. If there is a no vote, there will still be at least 46% of Scots who feel little or no affiliation with Britain, and we must not let that slip. Britain has to become a place that we feel proud to be a part of, and that means redistributing austerity more widely, and advancing social justice.

The standing order will be affected in how it addresses identity politics too, which will mean a massive reconsideration for the mostly English-only Conservatives.

That is not to say that the master puppeteers in the City are not secretly working their magic to retain the standing order; indeed, one aspect that has likely pushed towards ‘no’ in the recent polls is the Bank HQ scare, a supposed mass exodus of major banks like RBS to the south. Salmond called this bullying, but there are genuine repercussions that will be felt on a yes vote. Yet it is explicitly clear that, again, at least 46% of Scottish people refuse to be dissuaded by bankers’ arguments.

Once again, the masters –this time the financial powers- will have to re-evaluate their hold over a system that houses a people more resilient and defiant than once thought, or risk their markets.

Of course, this could also be proved wrong if we end up with an independent Scotland and a Conservative/UKIP coalition, with the latter putting on a facade of being anti-establishment but nevertheless being champions of the Thatcherite consensus, south of the border. Labour, in light of the inevitable electoral blow a yes vote would bring for them, would then have to reposition itself to the right, thus reciting the circle that had been permitted to play out after 1983.

But this scenario will be less likely, as the separatist movement has shown a keen hunger for something more, for regional autonomy, and for change. Separatists and regionalists have proven the biggest threat to the hegemony of the rich and to the otherwise unstoppable march for financial globalisation that has paid no attention to sovereignty before. The elite must surely now vouch for granting them their wishes or risk the continual erosion of the UK market.

One certainty will still remain; Cameron and neoliberalism’s culpability in a truly broken Britain, tearing at the seams (or perhaps Hadrian’s Wall), will not be forgotten. There is a revolt in the wings.

Photograph: Lawrence OP