A yes vote would be a victory for democracy

DSCN2983 - Copy

By William Pinkney-Baird

If you were to ask me why I support Scottish independence—why I came up to Scotland twice to help the yes campaign, in July and now in the week leading up to the referendum, despite not being Scottish—the answer is simple: democracy.

For me, and for many involved in the debate over Scotland’s future, the main issue at stake in this referendum is democracy, not nationalism, and certainly not Alex Salmond’s personal quest to recreate Braveheart. And a yes vote would be a massive victory for democracy, not only for Scotland, but also potentially the rest of the UK.

In 2010, Scotland returned one Tory MP, yet a Tory-led government was elected to Westminster, a government that little more represents the people of Scotland than a Scottish National Party government would represent the people of England. And in general, Westminster—and the political establishment—is becoming increasingly disconnected from the people it purports to represent, with regions outside of London and the South East of England increasingly pushed to the margins.

Surely it is better for democracy if the people of Scotland have the opportunity to elect their own government to represent their interests.

Ah, you might say, but the Scots now have a devolved parliament to look after their interests. That is certainly true, and while certainly a step in the right direction, it brings along many problems of its own.

Education is devolved in Scotland—managed by Holyrood rather than Westminster—but Scottish MPs still vote on issues of education, which allowed Scottish Labour MPs, unburdened by any sort of accountability to their constituents, to vote through increases of tuition fees for English students. And while the people of Scotland are overwhelmingly against nuclear weapons, the Trident nuclear submarines are stationed on the Clyde, at enormous expense to the taxpayer.

In an independent Scotland, all of these issues would be resolved—the people of Scotland would have a government that represents their interests on all issues (rather than being dictated by Westminster on issues such as economics and foreign affairs) and the people of England would no longer be affected by votes on issues devolved in Scotland from Scottish MPs not held accountable to their constituents.

But Scottish independence would bring even greater opportunities. The referendum has revitalised political engagement in Scotland, with 97% of the electorate (which includes 16 and 17 year olds) now registered to vote. Numerous groups have sprung up as a result of the discussion over the referendum—from the green and left oriented Radical Independence Campaign (RIC) to the artistic movement National Collective to the feminist Women for Independence.

While people in the rest of the UK are becoming increasingly disengaged with politics, the people of Scotland have begun to engage in a national conversation about the sort of country they want to live in.

There are a multitude of public meetings, artistic projects, and individual and shared visions of independence. In the case of a yes vote, this outburst of political engagement would inspire the drafting of a written constitution, and define the politics of the first generation of an independent Scotland.

And the benefits of independence would not just be felt in Scotland. A yes vote would be a direct challenge to the overly centralised and archaic Westminster government, showing the people of the rest of the UK that another way is possible. Scottish independence could pave the way towards greater regional devolution throughout the rest of the UK, bringing government closer to those it is supposed to represent.

And the example of political engagement seen in an independent Scotland could set alight the spark of democratic participation elsewhere in the UK.

Illustration: Patrick BrennanÂ