Why Jamie Oliver is a food fascist
At this point in an article I usually write my little spiel about how I respect the opposition, can understand where they’re coming from, etc., in order to make clear that opinion and politics need not be so vituperative as it normally is. This time I won’t. I hate Jamie Oliver, and I would not be particularly fussed if he were deported accidentally on trumped-up terrorism charges for, I don’t know, calling the Home Office ‘slightly inefficient’. I haven’t tried any of his recipes, granted, but I don’t want to. He’s put me right off anything vaguely to do with him.
Why? Because he is, to use a delightfully alliterative and not at all hyperbolic term, a food fascist. I don’t always agree with Boris Johnson. In fact, my college son, a staunch BoJo supporter, can testify that I was extremely vexed by his victory in London in May. But – although he then, under pressure from the media and the party leadership, had to withdraw it – he did say something very sensible in October 2006 when he was shadow higher education minister. This was “I say let people eat what they like. Why shouldn’t they push pies through the railings?” (in response to those parents who had taken to doing this for their children, now being forced by schools to eat ‘healthy’ food thanks to Oliver’s campaign). He did then call Oliver a ‘national saint’ after causing one of his trademark furores by these comments, but the point stuck, and I suspect a lot of people, whether privately or publicly, agreed with him.
Now, in the interests of full disclosure, I must admit that I attended an independent school in north London, with (for all that we complained about it) pretty good catering. I therefore can’t comment on how bad food in the state sector is. Clearly, it was far from good. So what I’m objecting to is not so much improving school dinners, as forcing out all ‘junk food’ (aka the tasty stuff, no school kitchen ever has the wherewithal to do decent ‘proper’ food) and virtually criminalising those who do eat such food (ie, people like me), even in conjunction with more healthy options. What especially annoys me is Oliver’s current campaign to make Rotherham eat healthily. What business of it is his if Rotherham doesn’t eat Savoy quality food every night? I’m not an apologist for Iceland, Cadbury’s, Walker’s, etc. – I know I shouldn’t eat quite as much junk food as I do. But there are so many subtler and better ways of encouraging people to eat better, and it should be acknowledged that a bit of junk food will not actually cause cardiac arrest in ten minutes.
Oliver has also turned a generation against ready meals; a discussion of this with a friend actually inspired this article, after he questioned the healthiness of such meals. Many ready meals are perfectly healthy and actually quite nice (even Iceland does a passable beef stew), and not everyone has the time, money or inclination to cook from scratch every night. Plus, cooking every single night makes it less special; it just becomes food for function, something one does as part of a daily routine with no zest to it.
I know the principal argument for culinary education: people who eat consistently unhealthy food get ill, go to hospital and the taxpayer foots the bill. But that way lies danger. What would be next? Most forms of adventuring (rock climbing, kayaking, etc.) would be banned on similar grounds. Depressive people would be forced to watch nothing but the Teletubbies to keep them from needing NHS treatment. It may seem reasonable, but it sets a precedent and thus begins the slow erosion of our freedom (and no, the similarity to civil liberty arguments is not a coincidence). My philosophical problem with the whole idea lies here; what we eat is one of those areas, like what we read, who we meet, who we sleep with, how we think, that the government and its surrogates (and let’s not pretend Oliver is anything else; the whole school dinners campaign, like Live8, smacked deeply of a government setup) should just keep well out of.
Oliver’s problem is that he, like so many, suffers from lack of fulfilment of the power process (see Theodore Kaczynski…aka the Unabomber)- whereby each human needs a goal and the effort of attaining it. Often, when people have their basic goals- survival- met too easily, they find new goals to strive towards, with no regard for the people that form part of their power process. Oliver needs therefore to mess around with everyone else’s lives with his incessant, holier-than-thou (was Boris actually pointing out the dangerous cult around him as some kind of Messiah Of Food with his ‘national saint’ remark?) food fascism because he has nothing better to do, such as earning a real living for example. Well, guess what, Jamie: my dinner is Pringles, cherry drops and mince pies and there’s not a thing you can do about it.
