Blogging? It’s just common sense

The World Wide Web may be getting on for twenty years old now, but it seems that many people still don’t fully understand it. Ask the average Durham student what the best thing about the Internet is, and they’ll very likely make reference to that stalking-tool extraordinaire, Facebook. The more studious among us might say DUO or JSTOR. But, as is becoming increasingly obvious, the Web’s real value lies in its democratization of information. Anybody can say whatever they like, effectively for free. Don’t like it? Don’t read it.

The establishment, of course, hates this. Ministers Andy Burnham and Hazel Blears have both gone on the record attacking political blogs, and in September the European Parliament tabled a – thankfully defeated – motion which would have lead to blogs being regulated by the state. In such circumstances, how could a blogger criticize the same state without fear of losing his official approval?

Politicians would love nothing more than to see blogging squashed. We have a free press, but professional journalists are so much easier to push around. If they publish something in a newspaper critical of a certain influential figure – the Prime Minister, say, or the Leader of the Opposition – they can’t really be surprised if their rivals are given the scoops before they are in future.

Quite apart from this, it is important to remember that the chief function of a newspaper is to make money. If something is unpopular with the audience, it won’t get published. Nor will something which disagrees with one of the advertisers, nor for that matter something which disagrees with the boss.

Anyone who doubts this need look no further than Mr. Murdoch and his prodigious influence over British politics. The blogger, on the other hand, has no editorial line to follow; he can write from his heart without thinking about his wallet.

This cult of the amateur is something to be welcomed, not feared. The acerbic Paul Staines, pseudonymously known as “Guido Fawkes” – “the only man to enter Parliament with honest intentions” – blogs daily on political sleaze, ferreting around Westminster, Sherlock Holmes-like, until the ugly truth is revealed. Remember Peter Hain, the permatanned Secretary of State for Work and Pensions? Guido’s investigation into his dodgy campaign funding is the reason why many of you probably don’t.

Yes, Guido’s biased. So are we all. So are print journalists. I defy anyone to tell me with a straight face that Polly Toynbee or Simon Heffer do not warp the facts to suit their own political ends.

And it is perhaps this bias which most alarms the centre-left establishment. The Internet as a whole is both right-wing and libertarian. Of the top twenty British political blogs, as compiled by the magazine Total Politics, only three can be described as left-wing. Why? All bloggers are on equal playing field; it’s a free market. Perhaps the British Left really did lose the argument in 1979. Or perhaps right-wing blogs are just more fun to read.

This, in itself, is rather odd. Bloggers are surely the cultural heirs of the radical pamphleteers of yesteryear. If Thomas Paine were alive today, he would be a blogger, and indeed “Common Sense” sounds like a great title for a vitriolic blog. In retrospect, we can see that Paine was vindicated by the success of the United States and the flourishing of its democracy; perhaps in two hundred years people will look back at the radical posts of Daniel Hannan, or Chris Mounsey of The Devil’s Kitchen, and think, hey, they were right too.

That is not to say, of course, that every blogger has something valuable to say. For every DUS speaker there are ten pub bores; for every considered philosopher there are twenty fascist cab-drivers. But the beauty of the Internet is that the bloggers with faulty logic, with irrational conclusions, with facile revelations, don’t get read. The blogs which thrive are those that are deemed as having something worthy of saying. Can one really say the same thing about the mainstream media, in a country where The Sun sells more copies every day than The Guardian sells in a week?

One of the examples given by Charlie Booth in the last edition of Palatinate of the blog’s supposed inferiority to the hack’s column was that the blog was free to defame characters and publish untruths. But the blog lives and depends on reputation to exactly the same extent as the print media do. If a crazy tramp on Elvet Bridge yelled that Gordon Brown eats babies, you’d think nothing of it. If I said it to you in private, you’d think I was a little odd. If it was printed on the front page of the Telegraph, why, then it’d be news.

There is no reason to believe why the stature and perceived accuracy of the better blogs should not match, or even exceed, the respectable newspapers in the future. And the world would be a better place for having journalists who could write how they truly felt, buoyed not by the stature of their rag but by their own reputation.