On deluded ‘left-wing’ imperialists
A common phrase in favour for the war in Iraq which I have heard from a few students recently, argues that “well, at least, the Iraqi people are better off without Saddam”. This argument was used in war cries by ‘left-wing’ writers such as David Aaronovitch and Christopher Hitchens prior to the invasion. However, the argument only makes sense if you completely ignore the truth coming out of the warzone.
Let’s start with deaths. There have been many independent studies and they give varying figures. The World Health Organisation (WHO) conducted a survey of 11,000 houses in 2007 and ranked the death toll as 151,000 for the first three years of the conflict. This however is one of the lowest figures. The respected Lancet Journal found that 655,000 had died up to June 2006, and that 601,027 were said to have occurred from violence rather than natural causes. The violence aspect is important here as the Oxford-based Iraqi Body Count found that invading forces have killed four times more civilians in the first two years of the war than the insurgents did. The government said that the Lancet figures were widely inaccurate, until the Ministry of Defence’s own advisor urged the government to be cautious about criticising the findings as the “study design is robust”. The British firm the Opinion Research Business did a recent study and believe there have been 1.2 million deaths ranging from a minimum of 733,000 to a maximum of 1,446,000. This isn’t fed to us through our TV sets.
The population is weakened as it is. The sanctions imposed on the Iraqi people really hurt the poor in society, killing, the UN estimates, 500,000 children and 1 million people overall. The ruthlessness of US and British actions was shown in a leaked Defence Intelligence Agency report: the ‘Iraq Water Treatment Vulnerabilities’ document written before the sanctions were imposed. It pointed out that certain sanctions imposed on Iraq would stop the importing of equipment and chemicals to make the water drinkable, which would dramatically increase illness and disease. Exceptions could have been made for the water system, especially considering the fact that Saddam was supposed to be punished; not innocent Iraqis. But exceptions weren’t made. And, now, since the fresh invasion, only 8 million – one quarter-of the Iraqi population – has access to clean drinking water.
The motivations for the sanctions were revealed early on by the then US secretary of state, James Baker: “Iraq will be turned into a backward and weak state”. By cutting supply lines they made the Iraqi people even more dependant on Saddam and just weakened his country, the Iraqi economy, his resources, his human resources. A man well put to explain this is Dennis Halliday, the former UN coordinator in Iraq who resigned in protest against the sanctions, ‘this policy constitutes genocide and Washington and London are responsible…It…is a deliberate policy to destroy the people of Iraq…We are in the process of destroying an entire society. It is illegal and immoral.’
You see, the US and Britain thought Saddam could be turned around after the first invasion and made to comply with western interests. Former CIA John Perkin’s explains the logic, “he’s the kind of strong man we like, he controls his people, we thought he could control the Kurds and keep the Iranians on their border and keep pumpin’ oil for us and once we take his military out he’s going to come around”. The point is that the US decided not to topple Saddam the first time, and instead chose to enforce sanctions on his already terrible society; the results were predictable and brutal. They fed a machine which they knew would produce certain results. And if you’re being honest, this constitutes camouflaged genocide.
“Yes but in the long term, the Iraqi people are better off”. This would depend on a democratic government supporting the Iraqi people, where they can support massive re-building projects. Perhaps there would be hope given Iraq’s vast oil wealth. However, the Iraqi Oil Law has recently been passed which gives US oil companies’ unrestricted access for the next 20 years, with the oil companies deciding how much revenue to give back to Iraq. Hopefully they’ll give enough back to rebuild an entire country. The Iraqi parliament is in the heavily defended green zone which is encircled by US tanks and marines. Obviously it is pro-west as no sane government would give away its oil resources for free to a foreign power. Its two largest factions are US-funded. Recent agreements privatised Iraq’s 200 state owned companies which really anchor the economy and provide basics such as cement to paper to cooking oil. Corporate tax was then reduced from 45% to 15% and the companies were allowed to sign contracts that insured control over these industries for forty years. Laws were then passed that allowed investors to take 100% of the profits they made from Iraq out of the country tax-free. Add to this the western corporate ownership of the Iraqi education and health systems etc, it really looks bleak. Even if a genuine democratic government developed in Iraq, it would still have no real power as the economy is effectively sown up.
Add to all this the fact that the US and Britain funded Saddam militarily through his worst atrocities against his own people; if someone is slaughtering people and you give him weapons then you’re involved – it’s a war crime. The invasion has also made Iraq a hotbed of insurgent terrorist groups; it’s hardly surprising the Iraqi people don’t like us.
So, unfortunately, the idea that the US and British actions in Iraq have helped the country is clearly wrong. The journalist Nir Rosen offers a more realistic analysis in a recent edition of Current History magazine: “Iraq has been killed, never to rise again. The American occupation has been more disastrous than that of the Mongols, who sacked Baghdad in the thirteenth century”.
