Christmas: The season to be jolly or the season of folly?
Scrooge
Chris Wright
There is an American legend kicking around that in Japan, which imported a version of Christmas from the West after WWII, a major department store once accidentally erected an immense, smiling, crucified Santa. My brief internet search cannot determine whether this really happened or is just a mildly xenophobic fairy tale, but either way it’s an image that pretty perfectly captures just how screwed up Christmas is.
It’s not the mirth and and the family gatherings and the presents and the feasting that bother me – it’s the fact that all this has to be blessed and vindicated by the most bizarre and incoherent mess of concepts.
First you take the nativity story (embellished from a sketchy Biblical account) and pin it onto the date, roughly, of the winter solstice (which since long before Christianity has been a pagan day to celebrate the birth of sun gods and hold riots and orgies, but has absolutely no relation whatsoever to the birth of Jesus). Then, as if we aren’t stretching credibility already, you throw in Scandinavian trees, a supernatural father-figure loosely based on a Saint who flies around in a sleigh pulled by reindeer giving presents to everybody (also partly sourced from a demonic Germanic spirit, and partly from a Coca Cola advert); then add a burning yule log, otherwise known – no sniggering – as the Great Ashen Faggot, and interweave the idea of the Twelfth Night, which has something vaguely to do with the signs of the zodiac.
Sift through the lyrics of any of the inane, endlessly repeated Christmas songs and you are likely to find several of these Christian and pagan motifs rubbing up against each other awkwardly. You see this most clearly in the music because, with stiff competition, it seems to be the most plastic and infantile of all the categories of “xmas” paraphernalia. From the demented: “Fa-la-la-la-la, la-la-la-la”, to the so-patronising-it’s-borderline-racist: “Do they know it’s Christmas time at all?” – songs for the festive season have a way of turning mindlessness into an art form. But that’s the point: you’re not supposed to think about the lyrics, you’re just supposed to swallow the lot, like we all do in childhood with all of it – I forgot to mention stockings, mistletoe, advent calenders, reruns of terrible movies, tinsel, for God’s sake – without even a thought for what any of it is supposed to mean. Yet it’s all somehow invested with the reverence and holiness of the nominally Christian theme.
Christians should take a moment to consider whether the Jesus gloss is sufficient justification for all this idolatry. If you take the Bible seriously, then presumably God wasn’t kidding when he announced, as reported in Jeremiah 10:2-4 “Do not act like other nations … Their ways are futile and foolish. They cut down a tree and carve an idol. They decorate it with gold and silver and then fasten it securely with hammer and nails so that it won’t fall over.”
More importantly, a festival which invariably involves spending lots of money on presents, food, alcohol and decoration, can hardly be seen as anything other than false consolation when compared with true salvation. The spirit of paganism remains the essential substance of the winter festival: the worship of Mammon, not God, is the source of Christmas cheer.
Which is why our favourite Protestant fundamentalist, Oliver Cromwell, who did so much to bring the form of idolatry known as monarchism to its deserved downfall, tried to ban Christmas as well. Appropriately enough, the Queen has her largest audience on Christmas day. While we’re in the mood for suspending our critical faculties, why not hear what platitudes Elizabeth II has for her subjects this year?
In an interview in 2007, the now deceased Norman Mailer expressed an important insight: “I’ve always felt that fascism is a more natural governmental condition than democracy. Democracy is a grace. It’s something essentially splendid because it’s not at all routine or automatic. Fascism goes back to our infancy and childhood, where we were always told how to live. We were told, yes, you may do this; no, you may not do that. So the secret of fascism is that it has this appeal to people whose later lives are not satisfactory.”
Routine, automatic and infantile: almost everything to do with Christmas could be described accurately with one or more of these terms. Maybe this sort of thing is so dangerous that it needs to be compressed into a few weeks and contained within its prison of sanctified nonsense? We all get together once a year to worship the saviour baby, to tell our children that Santa can see them when they’re sleeping, to note that niceness is to be rewarded with presents and naughtiness to result in mere coal. That way we get it out of our system.
But if you happen to trust that you would never have been part of any Nuremberg rally, no matter how bored or depressed you might have been living in Bavaria (if, to put it another way, you firmly do not wish it could be Christmas every day) then maybe when the season to be jolly comes wheeling round you should just sit back and enjoy the chocolate, while doing your best to ignore all the red and green plastic junk and, when the time comes for that ghastly carol from which the title of our debate derives, privately substitute in Tom Lehrer’s version:
Kill the turkeys, ducks and chickens,
Mix the punch, drag out the Dickens,
Even though the prospect sickens,
Brother, here we go again…
Tiny Tim
Amy Higgins
The lights are up in the Market Square, Klute is playing its Christmas playlist, for once, there is even snow on the ground. The festive season is upon us and I, for one, am bursting, unapologetically, with childish excitement.
And who can blame me? I have been waiting 12 months for this – the 1st of December – when the first door of my advent calendar might be rightfully opened and the Christmas period can begin in earnest.
I relish the sense of anticipation of the preceding weeks; it has all the intoxicating thrill of the chase minus the anticlimactic don’t-quite-fancy-them-as-much-as-you-thought-you-did bit. As to the main event, with its carols, cards, presents, stockings, crackers and parties, it easily outperforms Easter and is surely better than even the most extravagant 21st. And I haven’t even started on the food! Christmas promises a taste sensation of epic proportions: brandy butter melting over warm mince pies, honey glazed roast parsnips, turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce. Greediness and over-indulgence are not merely allowed but insisted upon; to ‘eat, drink and be merry’ is the name of the game.
I love it all, even those less obviously attractive aspects of Christmas: the needles that coat the floor of the living room because nothing but a ‘real’ tree would do; the attempt to play Monopoly that inevitably ends in embezzlement, tears and a row; the effort to smile gracefully when you find that the present that you were certain was a Mr. Frosty Ice Cruncher (as you had so carefully solicited from Father Christmas the week before) is in fact a Britannica Encyclopaedia (an experience of which I still bear the scars…).
In recent years however, a particularly miserable portion of humanity has been infringing on my love affair with Christmas. I am referring, of course, to those people who love to hate Christmas; those who boast loudly and proudly of their antipathy for the festival; those who whinge about how it has ‘lost its true meaning’, been usurped by Capitalism or something similarly grumpy. My advice to the anti-Christmas brigade? Life is short so have a little cheer! And may I point out to those to bemoan its fading religious nature in particular, that the origin of the phrase ‘Eat, drink and be merry for tomorrow we die’ is Ecclesiastes 8:15.
Yet there are other, perhaps more profound and certainly less materialistic reasons for my love of Christmas – and to which those disenchanted with Christmas might be more receptive. It is, at the risk of sounding nauseatingly sentimental, a time to stop and celebrate life; an opportunity to spend time with your family and friends not because you have to but because you want to. We are all used to taking our families for granted. A common groan of parents is that they are treated as chauffeurs, cooks and cleaners – and it is probably a fair complaint. Relationships between siblings can all too easily descend into ones of perpetual dispute and quarrelling. Christmas is a time when we can take a step back from the practicalities and complications of day-to-day life and simply take pleasure in each others company.
This is something I have only come to really appreciate as I have got older and particularly since I went away to University. My three older brothers have similarly spread their wings in recent years – living in Manchester, South-Korea and Barcalona respectively. These are brothers whom I have grown up with; yet whilst we used to bicker over the remote on a daily basis, I have now become accustomed to seeing them for only a few weeks each year. This makes the Christmas holiday particularly precious. Many families, especially as their members grow older, will tell a similar story.
We will do the same things we have done on Christmas day ever since I can remember: mass in the morning is followed by a full English before we all pile into the car to go to my Grandparent’s house where we will spend the rest of the day eating, talking, eating, arguing, eating, and – towards the end of the day – napping on the sofa in front of re-runs of Fawlty Towers. Sophisticated – no; but priceless – yes.
There is, it seems to me, something genuinely life-affirming in this yearly coming together of families. This is not to say that I don’t enjoy all the Epicurean trappings of the period, because I most assuredly do; but rather that if they were all taken away tomorrow, Christmas would still be my favourite holiday.
Cynics lambaste the season for its commercialism but I can truthfully say that I do not want anything for Christmas – and it has got nothing to do with the current economic situation. The simple act of sitting down to eat with my family on the 25th of December means far more to me than the latest incarnation of the i-pod or a cashmere jumper (although, Mum, if you’re reading – I wouldn’t say no to those either).
