Why boycott Israel?
DESPITE HAVING RUN up against the closing times of two separate venues, the DSU Council debate on boycotting Israel came to an end without really ever having started. Clarifying the motion and wrangling over how to vote on it was strangely lively, but it couldn’t be said that we arrived at much solid argument on the merits of a boycott.
Part of the reason why the debate was so inadequate was that the chairman – who, admittedly, had a tough job – tended to enforce the emerging consensus that the issue of a boycott should be determined without discussion of politics.
Instead of revisiting the history of the Israel-Palestine conflict, it was merely to be a premise for the discussion that – no matter the details – Israel is guilty of human rights abuses and international law violations. The imperative is then that Israel should be stopped from further crimes, and the question is simply how.
To depoliticise inherently political issues by appeal to international law is an established method of populist anti-imperialism. It is a helpful alternative to thinking about complex issues, but it assumes both that the UN in infallible in its judgements and that it enacts full responsibilty in all conflicts.
That ideal falls massively short of reality, as the tragic fiasco over the intervention in Iraq demonstraed. People in Bosnia, Rwanda and Darfur have noticed a few holes in the theory, too. So unless you expect the UN to build a big umbrella to protect Israel from Hamas rockets, there’s something a little presumptive in the notion that Israeli defence policy should be subcontracted to ‘the international community’.
The motion referred, for instance, to the fact that Israel’s actions in Gaza have been disproportionate. I don’t need to disagree with this to make my point: all I need to do is establish that there is a serious case on the other side.
To give just one example, Dr Brendan Simms, Professor of the History of International Relations at the Centre of International Studies at Cambridge, considers Operation Cast Lead in the broder geopolitical context and concludes: “The Israeli attack on Hamas is thus a legitimate attempt to secure Israel’s southern flank in preparation for the showdown with Iran over its nuclear programme, which is expected this year.”
Apparently, the chair of the DSU council meeting and those who spoke eloquently in favour of a boycott are of a different opinion, but their view shouldn’t have been set down as a limitation on the debate.
Human rights violations are firmer ground for neutral criticism. But if this is the motive for the boycott then we shall have to be told about those violations, and the violations in question cannot of course be merely allegations. Once this argument is established, the natural question will be: ‘Why Israel?’
There has to be a reason to propose a boycott of Israeli goods, and not – say – Chinese goods. Is it that we believe Israel has a worse human rights record than China? I doubt it. Some would say the motive is anti-Semitism, but this is a mistake. Israel is selected for criticism because there is a political orthodoxy that its policies are systematically immoral and unreasonable.
That is an orthodoxy based on a troubled and complicated history, fuelled by many Israeli crimes, but it is not an orthodoxy I am willing to take as a premise for our debate, nor one that I wish the DSU to replicate on my behalf.
Anti-Semitism only enters the argument tangentially, in that there is a danger of this political orthodoxy hardening into something altogether less wholesome. It’s no use being insensitive to the powerful currents of racial prejudice against Jews which are recognisable in Christian and Muslim societies. This will always be a source of vitriol for those who want Israel to be punished.
Almost ignored by the national press, some of the anti-Israel rallies in London over the winter have been worryingly thuggish. 55 police officers have reported minor injuries, which are currently under investigation. I will post a link on the Palatinate website to footage of riot police literally running from an angry mob, as traffic cones are hurled amid calls of ‘Get back, poofs’ and ‘Allah Akbar’.
A more eccentric target of these riots has been Starbucks. Outlets in London have been subject to graffiti, smashed windows and in one case a fire-bombing. The reason is that Starbucks has been the target of an internet campaign which, rightly or wrongly, alleges that the chairman, Howard Shultz, is a supporter of Israel.
It probably doesn’t help that Starbucks has replaced MacDonalds in the zeitgeist as the representative of American capitalism, nor does it help that the logo of Starbucks has something of the New World Order about it. This kind of stuff, in other words, is somewhere between politics and pathology.
Speaking of pathology, the inestimable spittle-merchant who represents Bethnal Green and Bow, George Galloway, recently instructed an angry crowd to ‘shut down the Israel shops’ – which is really more in the spirit of kristallnacht than Che Guevara. I suppose it could be claimed that Mr Galloway is deeply concerned about human rights violations and is unblemished by hatred and ignorance, but if there is no answer to the question ‘Why Israel?’ then it would be sensible to assume otherwise.
Unless the motive is rewritten purely in terms of human rights abuses, therefore, we will be voting on the legitimacy of Israeli policies. It seems to me ridiculous for the DSU to take a stance on such difficult and divisive issues, but if they are going to do so on our behalf then we will have to have a debate about those policies and it will have to include a little history.
There is a presumption – evident, for instance, in the appeal to the precedent of Apartheid South Africa – that to defy the Israeli government is to be on the right side of history. But shouldn’t we stop and think about the differences between Hamas and Nelson Mandela, or the differences between Israeli occupation of the West Bank and racially segregated toilets?
Those who proposed this boycott at the DSU council meeting appeared to think that such issues were irrelevant. Unless the proposal is refined for the referendum, to vote for a boycott would be to endorse this arrogant and ignorant false neutrality as well as to echo the demagoguery which has lately animated the streets of our capital city. Not in my name, thanks, not even with the best of intentions.
