DSU and Catholics
Anybody attending the DSU council meeting last Thursday will have noticed in the motion proposing a boycott of Israel, an allusion to anti-discrimination principles which the Union holds. It seems to me worth asking the question whether it is appropriate for the DSU to house an event staged by DICCU, the intention of which was to explain why Catholics are going to Hell.
“Truth comes before unity”, so their speaker did preach: There is a bizarre selective scepticism in the claim that textual analysis of the Bible determines such a harsh outcome for Catholics. It is odd that with such conviction members of DICCU can be sceptical of all other interpretations of the Bible which promise salvation. Anyway, logic of religion aside, why did the DSU rubber stamp this event?
One might say that the DSU caters for all forums of discussion, regardless of whether they are consistent with their policies or not. But where were those speaking for Catholicism at this event? Through filtered pieces of paper at the end of the discussion, only questions which the speaker felt like addressing were answered.
In fact the contrast between the Thursday night council meeting and the DICCU event could not be more striking – a rabble of opinionated students where opposition to the motion in question is actively sought versus an event which proclaims dogma over unity, doesn’t invite speakers to question that dogma and doesn’t allow direct points to be made from the floor.
Now, attacking ideas is fair game – and I think I am making a good distinction by attacking DICCU’s evangelism rather than the nice people who believe in it. However, this is something which their society seems incapable of recognising; DICCU ‘doesn’t believe in Catholics‘, reads the ‘big question’ website (which is probably as testable as any of their delusions are ever going to be).
Also according to their website, DICCU ‘don’t welcome Catholics‘: The DSU exist to represent all students, and as such they should never have supported DICCU in marginalising Catholics by providing the Fonteyn Ballroom as a platform to espouse their discriminatory pathology. Equally, the University should not have allowed DICCU to advertise the event outside the library, on university property.
It is a disgrace that any student society can preach against a section of the student body, not provide any opportunity for open debate and not receive even a word of criticism from our representatives. If DICCU want to give anti-Catholic sermons, the DSU should not break its democratic, anti-discrimination rules to accommodate them.
