Facebook needs a health warning
Facebook, that most ubiquitous of so-called ‘social-networking’ sites, has provoked consternation and outrage in recent weeks after it removed photos of a woman breast-feeding.
The site’s spokesman, Barry Schmitt, maintained that the deletion of the photos was in line with company policy. “Photos containing a fully exposed breast (as defined by showing the nipple or areola) do violate those terms (on obscene, pornographic or sexually explicit material) and may be removed,” he stated.
Nevertheless, protesters headed by U.S. mother Kelli Roman staged a demonstration outside the company’s headquarters in Palo Alto, California. Roman also created an online group entitled ‘Hey Facebook, Breast-feeding is not obscene!’ which encourages its members to upload breast-feeding pictures en masse.
Yet altogether more questionable than the site’s decision to remove the photos in the name of child protection is the fact that the mother in question chose to upload them in the first place, (although the idea that breast-feeding mothers on Facebook would be the first port of call for those seeking explicit material online does seem bizarrely naïve).
The willingness with which Roman and co. shared such images is certainly more disconcerting than the sight of the ‘fully exposed breast’, ‘nipple’ or even the exotic sounding ‘areola’ – all of which Facebook is so keen to shield us from.
Don’t get me wrong, I am just as much a fan of cute, chubby-cheeked babies as the next girl, and I’ve no doubt that breast-feeding is a natural and beautiful expression of the bond between mother and child. I’m just not convinced that Facebook – the most public of forums – is necessarily the right place to display this intimate and private union.
Sure, you might want to share these pics with close family and good chums. However, if Roman is anything like the vast majority of Facebook users, she will have amassed a distinctly motley crew of ‘friends’ with distant acquaintances and old flings featuring a little too heavily. Call me old fashioned, but I like to think that some things in life should remain sacred.
This incident is symptomatic of a general trend of what could diplomatically be termed ‘over-sharing’ on Facebook, MySpace, Bebo and the rest. We are subject to daily updates of the minutiae of other people’s lives (‘John is 699 words down. 1301 to go’; ‘Sophie is sleepy’; ‘James is LASH LASH LASH!!!’) Of course it is nice to be kept informed on what those you know and love are up to, but Pierre with whom you once enjoyed halting French small talk on a school exchange five years ago? I probably know more about one near stranger’s latest pregnancy than the father of the baby, and that can’t be right. She is to be called Rose and has already started kicking. Home birth planned. Cravings: pickles and peanut butter. Interested? I’m willing to bet you weren’t.
Still, it’s harmless enough I suppose. Photos however, can be more of a minefield: the profile picture of you posing oh-so-philanthropically with the orphans you saved on your gap year; the model-hot black and white one which bears little, if any, resemblance to how you really look.
My personal bête noire – ‘the couple’s album’ – can leave a particularly sour taste in the (singleton’s) mouth. Incidentally, I might be a cynic, but I must also confess myself as ‘guilty’ as anyone else.
I upload and de-tag with the best of them. I was even recently introduced to someone with whose full name and favourite TV shows I was already familiar… a low moment, I admit.
Facebook is undeniably a valuable and cost-effective way of keeping in contact with friends and family, especially when at university or travelling. And whilst social networking might encourage our more narcissistic instincts, surely it is an essentially harmless pursuit?
Not so according to new scientific research. For some the boundary between real and virtual worlds can become unhealthily blurred with serious psychological implications. Young people who have never known a world without the internet can become caught up in their fast moving virtual lives. They can begin to place less value on their real world identities, with serious consequences.
The Mental Health NHS Trust expert, Dr. Himanshu Tyagi, has expressed concern that such people are in danger of impulsive behaviour, even suicide. These are sobering thoughts indeed, but I do not mean to sensationalise or to cause undue alarm. It would be absurd to imply that all Facebook users are destined to a life of mental health problems; thankfully, Dr. Tyagi’s findings are applicable only to the most vulnerable sections of society.
