Who’s your favourite artist’s favourite… presidential candidate?

By Matthew Dodd

In September, 2024’s breakout superstar Chappell Roan attracted criticism by refusing to endorse Kamala Harris for the Presidency, asserting that she was ‘questioning both sides’. Her decision is somewhat anomalous among her peers, many of whom have utilised political endorsement as another piece of viral marketing – who can forget Charli XCX’s helpful clarification that “Kamala IS brat”? Her unwillingness to pledge her whole image to a Harris campaign which, as she says, does not fully represent her interests is an expression of nuanced critical thinking which has become somewhat lost in the 2024 election cycle.

Celebrity endorsements aren’t a new development: Frank Sinatra rallied for FDR, JFK, and Reagan, whilst Barbara Streisand endorsed Clintons in both 1996 and 2008. But, as Chappell Roan discovered, the atmosphere this cycle is different from before. When Madonna claimed Hillary Clinton was a “girl gone wild” destined to “snatch the presidency” in 2016, it came across as a crass moment of all-too-typical Democrat disconnect. In 2024, though, there is an expectation for public figures – from Taylor Swift to Mike Tyson – to declare their allegiance. The social media ecosystem of the 2020s has absorbed fashion, interests and politics into one amorphous idea of online identity, so it follows that celebrities are expected to bring politics into their public image. Interestingly, however, this increased demand for political engagement from celebrities seems in no way tied to any increased engagement in policy. We’ve yet to see Beyonce rallying for increased spending on subsidised healthcare, or Jake Paul encouraging his fans to vote in the interests of decreasing the national deficit. Instead, the focus has been on protecting the vague notions of democracy, justice and the American way – concepts which have subtly different connotations depending on who’s endorsing them. 

This increased demand for political engagement from celebrities seems in no way tied to any increased engagement in policy

This, perhaps, leads us to the central difference between this and other elections. The choice the two parties are aiming to present on the ballot is not between Conservatism and Liberalism, or low taxes and high taxes, or even Donald Trump and Kamala Harris: it is between the abstract feelings brought about by figures like Hulk Hogan, Billy Ray Cyrus and Andrew Tate and those associated with Beyonce, Lin Manuel-Miranda and Oprah Winfrey. In short, it’s about vibes. Do Americans want a Brat White House or MAGA one?

The underpinning notion here is insidious, that the lines between the two parties on policy have been blurred enough that they are now having to be redrawn in the vague arena of personality politics. It’s no secret that economic issues have been supplanted by social ones in recent years of western politics – it’s easier to get people excited about the apparent spectre of ‘gender ideology’ than about sensible fiscal management – but even these differences have become somewhat ambiguous. For many voters, the key defining difference between Democrat and Republican social agendas is the former’s support of abortion rights following the overturning of Roe V. Wade. It’s an important issue, if one that Democrats have been historically hazy on supporting legislatively, but it represents one of the very few strident stances the party has taken against the GOP. 

On trans rights, Harris has been evasive at best, telling NBC anchor that “I think we should follow the law” when asked whether trans people should have access to gender-affirming care. To the Democrats’ credit, this equivocation seems to be deliberate: an attempt to project the aura of responsible, uncontroversial government after the fallout of Biden’s withdrawal and given the razor-edge nature of the race as it stands. 

There is an idea of a Democrat and a Republican which is better represented by Beyonce and Hulk Hogan than by a fiscal and social policy

It is the same reason Harris hasn’t foregrounded the historic nature of her candidacy in the way Hillary Clinton did eight years ago. For the next two weeks, Harris’ job is to be the image of sensibility, not poking any of the many wasps’ nests that pepper the American political landscape. Still, it leaves the Harris campaign feeling somewhat toothless, distracting voters with the veneer of Grammy-winning artists and TikTok superstars in lieu of a clear political agenda.

In 2024, then, celebrity endorsements are simply another symptom of an electoral discourse which has become more cultural than political. There is an idea of a Democrat and a Republican which is better represented by Beyonce and Hulk Hogan than by a fiscal and social policy. As such, with but a few weeks to go and the race still on a knife edge, it’s only by consolidating these bases that both parties can draw their paths to the White House.

Image: Jason Martin via Wikimedia Commons