Flags, Flags, Flags!
By Matthew Dodd
Outside the Houses of Parliament, on Gerri Halliwell’s dress, across the bald head of a football fan bracing to watch his country lose on penalties: we plaster flags in all sorts of places. And yet, this summer’s ‘Operation Raise the Colours’ – a grassroots campaign allegedly started by the EDL’s Andy Saxon and co-opted by the British right to hang or otherwise display the English flag in all corners of the nation – has seen the question of how and why we exhibit our flag take on renewed gravity. There is, of course, nothing definitionally wrong about flying the nation’s flag. The obvious problem, however, is that events don’t exist in vacuums. This summer’s movement has been wound up in the recent wave of frequently violent anti-immigration protests and, in no small part, represents a backlash to the appearance of the Palestinian flag around the nation in solidarity with those affected by the ongoing war in Gaza. Suggesting the flag’s resurgence is mere national pride, then, is simple ignorance. Instead, the flag has been weaponised as a reactionary symbol of exclusion and xenophobia: in York, a Chinese takeaway was graffitied with the England flag and messages including ‘go home.’ There will, of course, be those flying the flag who are earnestly caught up in the ‘trend’ of it all and simply wish to show their sincere patriotism, but fascistic movements have always relied on the naivety of the well-intentioned. The other fact of note is that the flag seen graffitied and hung up over the summer is not the flag of the nation – the Union Jack – but rather that of the sub-national region England, the antique and often misunderstood St. George’s Cross.
The George’s Cross has never been the predominantly flown flag in England in its modern history; since 1603, the Union Jack has been the dominant national symbol. Indeed, it is only since the 1990s that the George’s Cross has found any popular usage in the modern day, in the context of national sports fixtures. The colonial connotations of the Union Jack are complicated to say the least, but the flag at least remains in principle a symbol of national unity. In contrast, the George’s Cross has long stood, as it has again this summer, as a symbol of division and subjugation. G.K. Chesterton noted such a phenomenon in Ireland in the years surrounding the establishment of the Free State, when it was the George’s Cross, rather than the national flag, which was ‘splashed from one end of Dublin to the other’. It was the George’s Cross that was adopted EDL and BNP in their campaigns of bigotry across the last fourty years, and it is those sorts of scenes with which the flag remains popularly associated. In its current iteration, this flag-worship is – like the period, the hamburger and right wing populism – a largely American import. We have never had the flag culture of our Atlantic neighbours; our politicians have never been expected to wear Union Jack pins, our children don’t pledge its allegiance in school. The co-opting of the movement by Nigel Farage’s Reform UK appears to be yet another effort to bring Trump-style populism to Britain. We might recall last year’s outrage at the colour-swapped flag on the England football kit – an outrage evidently forgotten by Mr Farage as he designed the Reform UK football jersey with a similarly redesigned Union Flag. The tossing of the flag around towns and villages does nothing to materially improve any of the conditions in England, the desecration of which is the apparent instigator of the movement. Its only purpose is to promote isolationism, against the rest of the world and even the other home nations.
That the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom should deign to pander to this wave of faux-patriotic vandalism, appearing somewhat gormlessly in front of a string of George’s Crosses hung across his mantle, is frankly disgraceful
That the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom should deign to pander to this wave of faux-patriotic vandalism, appearing somewhat gormlessly in front of a string of George’s Crosses hung across his mantle, is frankly disgraceful. Should Keir Starmer be serious about British – for it is Britain, not just England, he was elected to lead – patriotism, perhaps he ought to recall Labour’s great post-war leader, Clement Attlee. When he, like Mr Starmer, was swept to power with a huge majority, he pledged his government towards the building of a ‘New Jerusalem’: an aspirational promise to, through a policy of mass nationalisation and public investment, create a nation which worked for its people. The work of a patriotic government, Attlee understood, must be forward-facing, looking towards a better future rather than hearkening back to an imagined past. If Starmer wants to be patriotic, he should give up trying to desperately win over voters that were never his to begin with and get on with effecting the public-spirited change he was elected to deliver. For it is not in the masturbatory reverencing of a flag, nor the vandalism of roundabouts and lampposts, but by a collective effort to build a national infrastructure at the service of its citizens that we might, in the immortal words of William Blake, build Jerusalem in England’s green and pleasant land.
Image: Les Chatfield via Wikimedia Commons

